Tales of Psychiatry Featuring Dr. Ellen Bassuk, Daniel Schoonover and Susanne Antonetta


In this episode, Dr. Ellen Bassuk, and her son, Daniel Schoonover, talk about the book they co-authored, Between Two Worlds, and the struggles they have encountered with America’s mental health system. Then, Susanne Antonetta, author of The Devil’s Castle, makes the correlation between the horrors of the Holocaust and today’s practice of modern psychiatry in the United States.
Host Erik Fleming interviews Dr. Ellen Bassuk, her son Daniel Schoonover, and author Susanne Antonetta about two powerful books exploring mental health, care systems, and psychiatry's troubled history. Between Two Worlds recounts a mother and son's struggle for compassionate treatment and recovery, while The Devil's Castle traces Nazi-era eugenics and its echoes in modern psychiatry.
The episode blends personal testimony, professional insight, and historical research to highlight systemic failures, stigma, and hopeful paths forward through advocacy, peer support, and humane, holistic care.
00:05 - Welcome to A Moment with Erik Fleming
01:14 - The NBG Podcast Network
02:00 - Tales of Psychiatry
06:32 - Moment of News with Grace G
09:02 - Interviewing Dr. Ellen Bassuk and Daniel Schoonover
50:41 - Susanne Antonetta Joins the Podcast
01:31:00 - Closing Thoughts and Reflections
00:00:00.017 --> 00:00:06.117
Welcome. I'm Erik Fleming, host of A Moment with Erik Fleming, the podcast of our time.
00:00:06.417 --> 00:00:08.977
I want to personally thank you for listening to the podcast.
00:00:09.337 --> 00:00:12.737
If you like what you're hearing, then I need you to do a few things.
00:00:13.257 --> 00:00:19.397
First, I need subscribers. I'm on Patreon at patreon.com slash amomentwitherikfleming.
00:00:19.757 --> 00:00:24.637
Your subscription allows an independent podcaster like me the freedom to speak
00:00:24.637 --> 00:00:27.957
truth to power, and to expand and improve the show.
00:00:28.557 --> 00:00:32.837
Second, leave a five-star review for the podcast on the streaming service you
00:00:32.837 --> 00:00:35.577
listen to it. That will help the podcast tremendously.
00:00:36.217 --> 00:00:41.917
Third, go to the website, momenterik.com. There you can subscribe to the podcast,
00:00:42.297 --> 00:00:47.257
leave reviews and comments, listen to past episodes, and even learn a little bit about your host.
00:00:47.857 --> 00:00:51.857
Lastly, don't keep this a secret like it's your own personal guilty pleasure.
00:00:52.577 --> 00:00:57.097
Tell someone else about the podcast. Encourage others to listen to the podcast
00:00:57.097 --> 00:01:02.417
and share the podcast on your social media platforms, because it is time to
00:01:02.417 --> 00:01:04.177
make this moment a movement.
00:01:04.617 --> 00:01:10.177
Thanks in advance for supporting the podcast of our time. I hope you enjoy this episode as well.
00:01:15.377 --> 00:01:20.197
The following program is hosted by the NBG Podcast Network.
00:02:00.588 --> 00:02:05.888
Hello. Welcome to another moment with Erik Fleming. I am your host, Erik Fleming.
00:02:06.328 --> 00:02:11.768
So today, we're going to be talking a lot about psychiatry.
00:02:12.208 --> 00:02:17.388
As a matter of fact, I think the working title is going to be Tales of Psychiatry
00:02:17.388 --> 00:02:22.708
because we have two books that we're going to highlight.
00:02:22.708 --> 00:02:25.868
One was written by a mother and son team
00:02:25.868 --> 00:02:29.808
that deals with a
00:02:29.808 --> 00:02:38.048
mother who was in the profession of psychology dealing with a child who was
00:02:38.048 --> 00:02:46.568
diagnosed with a mental illness and the journey that they had together in dealing with that.
00:02:46.568 --> 00:02:53.108
You know, school and, you know, healthcare professionals, the whole nine yards, right?
00:02:53.768 --> 00:03:01.988
And then I have another young lady who has written a book about connecting the dots, right?
00:03:01.988 --> 00:03:11.868
And her focus was on what happened during World War II or even prior to World
00:03:11.868 --> 00:03:17.628
War II and how people that weâwell,
00:03:17.748 --> 00:03:25.828
I say people, I should say that we, I say people in the psychology field or psychiatry field evenâ.
00:03:28.120 --> 00:03:33.840
These are people that are held in high esteem, but maybe they shouldn't be because
00:03:33.840 --> 00:03:40.880
a lot of the stuff that they did led to what we now know as the Holocaust, right?
00:03:41.300 --> 00:03:45.140
A lot of the science that they did, a lot of the beliefs that they had.
00:03:45.380 --> 00:03:51.960
And she goes deep into that as well as, you know, gets personal with it because
00:03:51.960 --> 00:03:57.440
she's also neurodivergent. And I think that's the term that we should use.
00:03:58.860 --> 00:04:03.240
So it's going to be a really, really good show.
00:04:03.600 --> 00:04:10.080
It's real good discussions. People are being very open and also being very cerebral
00:04:10.080 --> 00:04:14.600
about the issues around mental health in America.
00:04:15.160 --> 00:04:18.140
So, again, I hope that piques your interest.
00:04:18.640 --> 00:04:23.800
It's an issue that I've dealt with personally.
00:04:24.040 --> 00:04:29.020
It's something that touches all
00:04:29.020 --> 00:04:32.260
of us Because we either are
00:04:32.260 --> 00:04:37.660
related to or know somebody That has gone through those challenges So I hope
00:04:37.660 --> 00:04:44.180
that this episode gives you some enlightenment But also gives you some hope
00:04:44.180 --> 00:04:49.960
Because that's what we try to do on this podcast Is continue to give people hope,
00:04:50.700 --> 00:04:53.360
No matter how dark the times are.
00:04:54.206 --> 00:05:01.866
And if you support what this podcast is doing, please show it either through
00:05:01.866 --> 00:05:07.126
subscriptions or, you know, just continue to listen and spread the word.
00:05:07.286 --> 00:05:16.106
You can go to www.momenteric.com and find out anything and everything you want
00:05:16.106 --> 00:05:17.086
to know about the podcast.
00:05:17.506 --> 00:05:22.586
If you missed an episode and you want to go back, you can do it that way.
00:05:23.166 --> 00:05:29.846
Again, the subscription piece, you want to learn a little bit about me, you can do that as well.
00:05:30.006 --> 00:05:38.166
So I encourage y'all to do that, and I thank you all for your continued support by listening.
00:05:39.566 --> 00:05:43.946
I want to say this before I do my normal kickoff.
00:05:45.526 --> 00:05:51.286
The young lady, Grace G, that does the news segment, she just recently had a birthday.
00:05:51.286 --> 00:05:57.126
And I let it kind of slip because I could have said something in advance last
00:05:57.126 --> 00:06:01.426
week's episode, but I want to acknowledge the fact that she had a birthday.
00:06:02.266 --> 00:06:07.626
And from what I understand, she had a really, really good time celebrating it.
00:06:07.626 --> 00:06:14.166
And I just want to congratulate her on another year and continue to thank her
00:06:14.166 --> 00:06:17.526
for her contributions to this podcast.
00:06:17.526 --> 00:06:24.586
She has really been a blessing, and I have words can't express the gratitude I have.
00:06:25.146 --> 00:06:32.646
So on that note, ladies and gentlemen, it's time to kick off another episode.
00:06:32.646 --> 00:06:37.426
And as always, we kick it off with a moment of news with Grace G.
00:06:44.816 --> 00:06:50.136
Thanks, Erik. Representative Eric Swalwell announced his resignation from Congress
00:06:50.136 --> 00:06:54.496
and the suspension of his California gubernatorial campaign amid a Manhattan
00:06:54.496 --> 00:06:59.056
District Attorney investigation into multiple allegations of sexual assault.
00:06:59.636 --> 00:07:04.276
Representative Tony Gonzalez of Texas announced his retirement from Congress
00:07:04.276 --> 00:07:10.036
following his admission of an affair with a former staffer who tragically died by self-immolation.
00:07:10.036 --> 00:07:15.916
Progressive Democrat Annelia Mejia won a special election in northern New Jersey
00:07:15.916 --> 00:07:17.796
to fill a vacated House seat.
00:07:18.036 --> 00:07:23.096
Todd Lyons, the acting head of ICE, will leave the agency at the end of May.
00:07:23.496 --> 00:07:28.616
President Trump nominated Erica Schwartz, a former deputy surgeon general,
00:07:28.796 --> 00:07:31.416
to serve as the next director of the CDC.
00:07:32.136 --> 00:07:36.816
Authorities confirmed that former Virginia Lieutenant Governor Justin in Fairfax
00:07:36.816 --> 00:07:42.036
died in a murder-suicide after fatally shooting his wife, Serena Fairfax,
00:07:42.196 --> 00:07:43.576
at their Annandale home.
00:07:43.796 --> 00:07:49.736
In a historic political shift, Hungary's Viktor Orban was ousted after 16 years
00:07:49.736 --> 00:07:54.916
in power by Peter Majar's TISA party, which secured a supermajority.
00:07:55.436 --> 00:08:00.156
President Trump ordered a U.S. Navy blockade of the Strait of Hormuz to stop
00:08:00.156 --> 00:08:03.876
all maritime traffic to and from Iranian ports.
00:08:04.136 --> 00:08:06.516
A federal judge dismissed President
00:08:06.516 --> 00:08:10.636
Trump's defamation lawsuit against the Wall Street Journal. A U.S.
00:08:10.976 --> 00:08:15.076
Appeals court blocked a lower court's investigation into whether the Trump administration
00:08:15.076 --> 00:08:20.056
willfully ignored orders to halt deportation flights of Venezuelan immigrants.
00:08:20.356 --> 00:08:26.576
Former Vice President Kamala Harris confirmed she is weighing another presidential bid in 2028.
00:08:27.334 --> 00:08:31.734
The World Bank launched its Water Forward Initiative, which aims to provide
00:08:31.734 --> 00:08:38.194
secure water access to 1 billion people within four years across 14 water-stressed countries.
00:08:38.834 --> 00:08:45.634
And NASA's Artemis II mission successfully concluded as the Orion capsule splashed
00:08:45.634 --> 00:08:51.134
down in the Pacific, marking the first time humans returned from the moon in over half a century.
00:08:51.754 --> 00:08:57.594
I am Grace Gee, and this has been a Moment of News. Bye.
00:09:02.587 --> 00:09:08.927
All right. Thank you, Grace, for that moment of news. And now it is time for my guests, Dr.
00:09:09.207 --> 00:09:12.767
Ellen Bassuk and Daniel Schoonover.
00:09:13.267 --> 00:09:17.987
Ellen Bassuk, MD, is a psychiatrist, researcher, clinician,
00:09:18.007 --> 00:09:22.707
and advocate whose five-decade career has focused on mental health,
00:09:23.067 --> 00:09:27.327
homelessness, and vulnerable populations, especially families and children.
00:09:27.567 --> 00:09:32.447
She has served as associate professor of psychiatry at Harvard Medical School
00:09:32.447 --> 00:09:35.287
for nearly 40 years, and is the
00:09:35.287 --> 00:09:40.147
founder of the National Center on Family Homelessness and C4 Innovations.
00:09:40.347 --> 00:09:44.507
The author of more than 150 peer-reviewed publications,
00:09:44.967 --> 00:09:50.727
she is a distinguished life fellow of the American Psychiatric Association,
00:09:51.067 --> 00:09:55.687
has received numerous honors, including an Honorary Doctorate from Northeastern
00:09:55.687 --> 00:09:58.007
University, the Blanche F.
00:09:58.267 --> 00:10:01.967
Idelson Award for the Promotion of Children's Mental Health,
00:10:02.187 --> 00:10:08.007
and the American Psychological Association Distinguished Contribution to Child Advocacy Award.
00:10:08.227 --> 00:10:10.827
She lives in Boston, Massachusetts.
00:10:11.307 --> 00:10:16.827
Her son, Daniel Schoonover, is a devoted animal lover and volunteer committed
00:10:16.827 --> 00:10:20.687
to supporting overlooked creatures and communities.
00:10:20.927 --> 00:10:25.767
With hands-on experience in herpetology and marine life care,
00:10:26.007 --> 00:10:31.227
including work at the Woods Hole Science Aquarium and the MSPCA,
00:10:31.367 --> 00:10:34.727
he has spent much of his life nurturing the natural world.
00:10:34.987 --> 00:10:39.607
Currently studying at the Boston University Center for Psychiatric Rehabilitation.
00:10:40.307 --> 00:10:44.127
Daniel is deepening his knowledge of spirituality, recovery,
00:10:44.147 --> 00:10:50.127
and wellness while continuing his exploration of herpetology.
00:10:50.287 --> 00:10:55.207
He also volunteers at a food bank, plays electric and acoustic guitar,
00:10:55.527 --> 00:10:57.087
and practices martial arts.
00:10:57.744 --> 00:11:04.464
Whether caring for animals or helping others, Daniel is dedicated to making a meaningful impact.
00:11:04.824 --> 00:11:08.804
Together, Ellen and Daniel wrote the book Between Two Worlds,
00:11:09.164 --> 00:11:14.024
a psychiatrist and her son's quest for compassionate mental health care.
00:11:14.184 --> 00:11:20.944
And we'll be talking about that book and their viewpoints on mental health in
00:11:20.944 --> 00:11:22.984
America during the interview.
00:11:22.984 --> 00:11:25.124
So, ladies and gentlemen, it
00:11:25.124 --> 00:11:32.344
is my distinct honor and privilege to have as guests on this podcast, Dr.
00:11:32.564 --> 00:11:35.124
Ellen Bassuk and Daniel Schoonover.
00:11:46.275 --> 00:11:55.975
All right. Dr. Ellen Bassuk and Daniel, I'm going to mess it up, Schoonover.
00:11:56.635 --> 00:11:59.675
Did I get it right? You got it right. Yay.
00:12:00.335 --> 00:12:04.875
Okay. How y'all doing? Y'all doing good? Yes. Doing great. Doing great.
00:12:05.015 --> 00:12:06.675
Well, I'm glad to have y'all on.
00:12:08.295 --> 00:12:14.315
I think y'all are going to be the first father, I mean father, mother, son,
00:12:15.615 --> 00:12:21.215
author combo that i've had on the show and y'all have written this book called between two worlds.
00:12:22.515 --> 00:12:30.495
And can i can i tell y'all something it was it was a book that you know i felt,
00:12:31.175 --> 00:12:38.995
some relief about it but i felt a little angry when i read it and about huh
00:12:38.995 --> 00:12:42.495
about what parts of Well.
00:12:43.275 --> 00:12:46.875
And we'll get into it, you know, as we get into the interview,
00:12:47.195 --> 00:12:56.675
but I kind of felt angry because of all the stuff that Daniel had to deal with, right?
00:12:56.675 --> 00:12:59.895
And and of course you being
00:12:59.895 --> 00:13:03.275
the mom you know and so
00:13:03.275 --> 00:13:06.635
i didn't i kind
00:13:06.635 --> 00:13:09.375
of thought you know okay yeah there's some
00:13:09.375 --> 00:13:13.015
you know there's going to be some adversity all
00:13:13.015 --> 00:13:16.335
that stuff but it was just kind of like when i was reading it i was
00:13:16.335 --> 00:13:24.755
like going i you know there was one particular part where I have to think back
00:13:24.755 --> 00:13:30.955
to when I was like in kindergarten and my mom had to show up at the school and
00:13:30.955 --> 00:13:34.195
get on a on a teacher and a principal. Right.
00:13:34.655 --> 00:13:41.755
And I just said, and the restraint that you had in certain situations was very admirable.
00:13:42.495 --> 00:13:47.735
But I don't know if I would have handled it as smooth, but we'll get into that
00:13:47.735 --> 00:13:52.275
because I don't want to belabor on my part.
00:13:52.435 --> 00:13:58.595
But I just thought I'd share that with you, that it was very compelling what you wrote.
00:13:59.455 --> 00:14:04.075
So normally what I do is that I start off with icebreakers.
00:14:04.315 --> 00:14:09.795
And so the first icebreaker, Dr. Ellen, what I want you, I want you to answer
00:14:09.795 --> 00:14:12.255
this quote or respond to this quote.
00:14:12.495 --> 00:14:17.775
We have a mental health system that is dominated by political and hidden forces
00:14:17.775 --> 00:14:22.915
that keep us stagnated and unable to see real lasting change.
00:14:23.115 --> 00:14:24.555
What does that quote mean to you?
00:14:25.315 --> 00:14:31.275
From my point of view, the mental health system reflecting some of the problems
00:14:31.275 --> 00:14:39.375
in the general health care system is in relative collapse and needs all kinds
00:14:39.375 --> 00:14:42.295
of sustenance at this point. And.
00:14:44.765 --> 00:14:50.005
It starts from the top down. There aren't enough practitioners.
00:14:50.005 --> 00:14:51.945
There aren't enough beds.
00:14:52.205 --> 00:14:56.105
There's not enough patient responsiveness.
00:14:57.525 --> 00:15:04.765
There's not enough money in the system in rural areas, underserved populations,
00:15:05.145 --> 00:15:09.305
vulnerable populations. The services are very sketchy.
00:15:09.805 --> 00:15:16.445
That's one part of it. The other part of it is that seriously mentally ill people,
00:15:16.805 --> 00:15:22.385
which generally refers to schizophrenia, bipolar, and serious depressions,
00:15:22.605 --> 00:15:28.925
have not been properly or adequately researched at this point.
00:15:29.725 --> 00:15:33.205
And we really don't know a lot about them.
00:15:33.525 --> 00:15:39.465
The DSM, you know, the dictionary that tells you the list, is really just a
00:15:39.465 --> 00:15:43.665
collection of symptoms. It doesn't tell you about course, outcome,
00:15:44.405 --> 00:15:46.345
treatment, most importantly, treatment.
00:15:47.365 --> 00:15:56.705
So there aren't markers for what you need to do to really manage and care for these illnesses.
00:15:57.965 --> 00:16:05.545
And what's happened is that there's been a lot more collaboration now with primary care.
00:16:05.545 --> 00:16:12.145
And they've become, to a large degree, without the seriously mentally ill,
00:16:12.345 --> 00:16:18.025
the primary caretakers for a lot of people with mental health issues.
00:16:18.465 --> 00:16:23.585
The system is shifting and it's not necessarily in a good way.
00:16:24.105 --> 00:16:29.325
So it's basically, to sum it up, it's a mess.
00:16:30.485 --> 00:16:35.245
All right, Daniel, I want you to do the honors of...
00:16:36.085 --> 00:16:41.165
Starting off this icebreaker. Now, either one of you can answer.
00:16:41.225 --> 00:16:43.405
It's what we call 20 questions.
00:16:43.785 --> 00:16:47.825
So either one of you can answer the question. But, Daniel, I want you to pick
00:16:47.825 --> 00:16:49.625
a number between 1 and 20.
00:16:50.365 --> 00:16:53.925
Between 1 and 20? Yeah, this is 13. Okay.
00:16:54.685 --> 00:17:04.065
All right. Y'all's question is, do you think there's such a thing as unbiased news or media and why?
00:17:04.645 --> 00:17:11.105
No no i don't believe there's unbiased news or media because this country is completely divided.
00:17:12.165 --> 00:17:18.245
And and it's it's it's it's not only is it well this country is like literally
00:17:18.245 --> 00:17:25.065
been completely divided and you know ever since it was a country and you know
00:17:25.065 --> 00:17:28.265
i seeing you know fox 25 but seeing CNN,
00:17:28.905 --> 00:17:34.325
yeah, they're both entirely different, an entirely different view,
00:17:34.365 --> 00:17:36.905
and they portray everything entirely differently.
00:17:37.145 --> 00:17:39.265
It's like brainwashing, even.
00:17:40.125 --> 00:17:45.145
Okay. Yeah. Well, go ahead, Doc, if you want to add to that.
00:17:45.625 --> 00:17:49.845
Oh, I think there is a huge amount of misinformation.
00:17:50.425 --> 00:17:56.725
You don't know what's true anymore, what's not true. And given the divisions,
00:17:56.745 --> 00:18:02.905
which have gotten more and more extreme and have excluded large groups of people,
00:18:03.345 --> 00:18:08.705
you can't depend on the news to tell you really what's going on.
00:18:09.925 --> 00:18:14.905
It sure does look bad, though, from all of you. Yeah, it's total.
00:18:15.685 --> 00:18:19.565
Say that again, Daniel? Total disinformation, and it's very confusing.
00:18:20.185 --> 00:18:24.985
And it's very frustrating these days not to be able to know exactly or at least
00:18:24.985 --> 00:18:27.445
pretty much what's going on. It's frustrating.
00:18:28.005 --> 00:18:36.205
Yeah, it's very frustrating. And, you know, I've asked this question to several guests before.
00:18:38.005 --> 00:18:40.885
And mostly everybody is, you know,
00:18:41.605 --> 00:18:45.105
they've kind of, they've all come to the same conclusion that you came to,
00:18:45.225 --> 00:18:48.765
Daniel, but you're the first one to actually say the word brainwashing,
00:18:48.925 --> 00:18:51.765
believe it or not, in all these interviews I've done,
00:18:52.125 --> 00:18:58.965
which, you know, it does seem like that to a degree, you know,
00:18:59.145 --> 00:19:03.885
and if you, but people get defensive when you say that.
00:19:03.885 --> 00:19:07.125
So but I'm glad that you said it out loud.
00:19:07.545 --> 00:19:10.125
So why did I guess?
00:19:11.065 --> 00:19:14.365
Dr. Ellen, this would be more towards you.
00:19:14.505 --> 00:19:19.285
Why did you decide to write between two worlds?
00:19:19.965 --> 00:19:26.545
And then, Daniel, your question would be, why did you decide to help your mom write this book?
00:19:29.901 --> 00:19:37.521
Well, it's one of the only books that I know of that tell the lifelong story
00:19:37.521 --> 00:19:45.321
of serious mental illness and the obstacles that are in the way of adequately
00:19:45.321 --> 00:19:48.501
treating it and the need,
00:19:48.881 --> 00:19:52.261
given the current system and our current state of knowledge.
00:19:53.121 --> 00:19:55.981
To get creative at a certain point.
00:19:56.161 --> 00:20:02.201
I mean, I was a company person at the beginning, you know, trained in,
00:20:02.361 --> 00:20:07.581
I was at Harvard, trained in classical dynamics,
00:20:08.101 --> 00:20:12.581
psychiatry, and it doesn't fit the bill for any of this.
00:20:12.741 --> 00:20:18.961
And so over time, you sort of have to figure out how to step away from the system
00:20:18.961 --> 00:20:24.861
and create something that is going to be meaningful and is going to work.
00:20:25.061 --> 00:20:30.621
And there are emerging models out there, particularly the recovery model,
00:20:30.841 --> 00:20:32.741
which doesn't mean cure.
00:20:33.121 --> 00:20:39.561
The recovery model is in some ways a partial takeoff from some of the AA stuff.
00:20:40.361 --> 00:20:45.761
But we eventually set up our own treatment team, right, Dan? Yes.
00:20:45.981 --> 00:20:52.201
And in fact, some of the caretakers on it are people with lived experience who
00:20:52.201 --> 00:20:56.741
have been there. They know what the system is like. They know what you're up against.
00:20:57.561 --> 00:21:02.101
And they treat the illness as just one part of the human experience.
00:21:02.101 --> 00:21:03.701
It's not the whole person.
00:21:04.181 --> 00:21:10.441
And what began to really make a difference was stepping away.
00:21:11.201 --> 00:21:18.161
But we traveled through it, unfortunately, and Danny suffered a lot. Yeah. Yeah.
00:21:19.351 --> 00:21:25.251
Okay, so why did I choose to take part in writing this book and contribute my time and efforts?
00:21:26.251 --> 00:21:31.511
Well, I knew that if I contributed to this book, it was going to be totally
00:21:31.511 --> 00:21:33.031
relevant to my life anyway.
00:21:33.331 --> 00:21:37.571
That if it got published, it would be one of the greatest achievements of my life.
00:21:37.671 --> 00:21:41.331
And I wanted to address the fact that the system is broken.
00:21:41.631 --> 00:21:46.771
The mental health system and the educational system, it's totally broken these days.
00:21:48.311 --> 00:21:53.211
And I wanted to address that and I wanted to do it carefully,
00:21:54.011 --> 00:21:59.031
and I think it's been done in that manner and I'm really proud of myself for
00:21:59.031 --> 00:22:06.271
being a part of this I would not have refused if I went back in time and I got
00:22:06.271 --> 00:22:09.551
re-asked to be a part of the book I'd say yes,
00:22:09.651 --> 00:22:12.351
no regrets here Yeah, that's cool,
00:22:13.131 --> 00:22:17.451
Doc, how far along were you in your career when Daniel was born.
00:22:18.559 --> 00:22:23.959
Well, let's see, Daniel, is I was fairly far along.
00:22:24.399 --> 00:22:32.099
At that time, I had been on staff at one of the Harvard Teaching Hospitals and
00:22:32.099 --> 00:22:35.979
then went to the Bunting Institute at Radcliffe,
00:22:36.139 --> 00:22:42.999
which was a women's institute that's now called Radcliffe Advanced Studies.
00:22:44.039 --> 00:22:49.079
And it was at that point that Danny was born. And so I was a fellow at the time
00:22:49.079 --> 00:22:54.399
and already in the homeless world.
00:22:55.239 --> 00:23:02.599
Yeah. So how did Daniel's journey impact your life work? Did it good and bad?
00:23:04.999 --> 00:23:11.359
Yeah. So that's kind of like why I led into the interview kind of saying how
00:23:11.359 --> 00:23:15.859
the book made me feel because I kind of got good and bad out of it.
00:23:15.859 --> 00:23:18.779
So how did it impact you, good or bad?
00:23:19.539 --> 00:23:23.199
Well, it was hard going.
00:23:23.719 --> 00:23:30.119
Danny initially had a diagnosis of Tourette, which was very disruptive in the school system.
00:23:30.299 --> 00:23:32.799
They had no clue about how to handle it.
00:23:32.999 --> 00:23:38.779
We had consultants for it, and it made no difference because they don't have
00:23:38.779 --> 00:23:44.759
the training, the resources, the money for any vulnerable,
00:23:45.159 --> 00:23:48.819
disadvantaged groups, including people with no resources.
00:23:48.859 --> 00:23:53.119
They are very disadvantaged in these systems.
00:23:53.539 --> 00:23:58.099
And as we, let's see, where should I take this?
00:23:59.312 --> 00:24:04.752
Okay, I got lost here. Where might they get the funding from?
00:24:05.012 --> 00:24:12.892
They don't have that. Right, and particularly now with this administration of the DEI.
00:24:15.392 --> 00:24:19.392
That's ridiculous. It's just such a huge problem.
00:24:19.832 --> 00:24:25.572
And you can't use those words anymore, and you have to sort of skirt around it.
00:24:25.912 --> 00:24:33.152
But the system is a mess, And they don't fully take care of people.
00:24:33.612 --> 00:24:37.752
Well, yeah, you would want their training of these people to be a bit more rounded.
00:24:38.392 --> 00:24:46.232
Yeah, yeah. And, you know, as I went along, I moved further and further away
00:24:46.232 --> 00:24:48.752
from the traditional system. It wasn't working.
00:24:49.172 --> 00:24:55.312
Right. But I also got involved in the homeless world and with homeless families
00:24:55.312 --> 00:24:58.792
who were, at that point, not even on the map.
00:24:59.312 --> 00:25:05.592
I mean, this goes back to, I started with that in about 1990,
00:25:05.652 --> 00:25:11.512
so it's a long time ago, but it was right at the beginning of family homelessness,
00:25:11.872 --> 00:25:17.912
which is dominated by children below the age of six, many of whom have been traumatized.
00:25:18.772 --> 00:25:24.432
Everybody's poor, they don't have resources, and they need advocates,
00:25:24.572 --> 00:25:29.052
they need people who are going to speak for them, They need to be supported
00:25:29.052 --> 00:25:30.332
to speak for themselves,
00:25:30.672 --> 00:25:37.712
and there still needs to be changes in that part of the system.
00:25:39.112 --> 00:25:45.212
The percentage of severely mentally ill in the homeless population is mainly
00:25:45.212 --> 00:25:51.112
in the unsheltered groups and in the chronic groups, but they're not taken care of.
00:25:51.840 --> 00:25:56.080
And this society should be able to manage it.
00:25:56.320 --> 00:26:04.400
And I felt a certain amount of outrage about it all, and it affected me because it affected my kid.
00:26:04.800 --> 00:26:14.420
And all I could do was either argue with them, which never had any reasonable outcomes,
00:26:14.700 --> 00:26:22.380
so we didn't do that, But to sidestep them and to begin to create our own direction
00:26:22.380 --> 00:26:25.240
that I thought would have a chance.
00:26:25.540 --> 00:26:30.520
I've really supported Danny, and over time, it has.
00:26:31.080 --> 00:26:35.420
But it involved, and this is the direction some of it's going,
00:26:35.800 --> 00:26:39.100
it involved a lot of what they call peer workers,
00:26:39.700 --> 00:26:48.300
people who have been there, people who have had similar difficulties who understand.
00:26:48.540 --> 00:26:51.880
Right. And all this, and building up my treatment team, it helps me.
00:26:52.360 --> 00:26:55.620
But the question is, how do we help everyone else too?
00:26:56.180 --> 00:27:01.920
This book is set in that direction, helping everybody else too. Yeah.
00:27:02.600 --> 00:27:10.980
So, you know, I, my, my experience, even though I did teach for a minute,
00:27:11.360 --> 00:27:14.840
a lot of my life experience as far as work has been law enforcement.
00:27:15.260 --> 00:27:20.760
And I remember there was a situation where fellow deputy had brought somebody
00:27:20.760 --> 00:27:28.520
to the jail and, you know, they described this person as being combative and, you know.
00:27:29.974 --> 00:27:33.814
Being, you know, so they had like disturbing the peace charges, all that stuff.
00:27:34.674 --> 00:27:40.734
And, you know, when I was doing the intake for him, he had an outburst.
00:27:41.714 --> 00:27:46.994
And I just asked him, I said, do you have Tourette's?
00:27:47.354 --> 00:27:52.314
And he looked at me and his eyes got big and he said, yeah, I've been diagnosed with Tourette's.
00:27:52.614 --> 00:27:55.374
And I said, when was the last time you took your medication?
00:27:55.714 --> 00:27:58.474
He said, oh, probably been about a month.
00:27:59.358 --> 00:28:02.918
So I was, and I hadn't been trained
00:28:02.918 --> 00:28:06.898
in that, but I had been exposed to it because I'm a big baseball guy.
00:28:06.998 --> 00:28:12.198
And there was a guy that played baseball I liked named Jim Eisenreich, and he had Tourette's.
00:28:12.898 --> 00:28:17.138
And he made it to the major leagues. And so he would do things like when he
00:28:17.138 --> 00:28:22.118
would come up to bat and the announcer said that. And I was young at the time.
00:28:22.558 --> 00:28:28.078
And the announcer went into this whole thing about Tourette's. So I picked up on that.
00:28:28.798 --> 00:28:33.718
So, you know, the deputy didn't know that. And whoever filed a complaint against
00:28:33.718 --> 00:28:35.898
the man didn't know that, or else he wouldn't have been in the jail.
00:28:37.058 --> 00:28:45.518
So I related to that part when people could not relate to Daniel at the school,
00:28:45.518 --> 00:28:50.018
because it's not just, it's in society in general.
00:28:50.718 --> 00:28:53.598
Which kind of leads me to ask this question with Daniel.
00:28:54.338 --> 00:28:57.518
Your mom can give us the technical term of
00:28:57.518 --> 00:29:00.358
what schizophrenia is but i want you
00:29:00.358 --> 00:29:03.598
to describe it in your own words what what
00:29:03.598 --> 00:29:06.418
what it is not technical terms what
00:29:06.418 --> 00:29:13.938
you might call layman's terms yeah yeah oh oh it's it's so it's a disorder but
00:29:13.938 --> 00:29:19.558
that that's getting technical so basically what's your experience like what's
00:29:19.558 --> 00:29:23.918
my experience like with schizophrenia yeah it's a really,
00:29:24.158 --> 00:29:26.298
really long journey.
00:29:26.518 --> 00:29:33.218
It's like two, one step forward, two steps back again and again and again. But what goes on?
00:29:33.578 --> 00:29:38.838
Well, let's grab some of it. But what goes on is I have my visual and auditory
00:29:38.838 --> 00:29:40.058
hallucinations all day.
00:29:41.416 --> 00:29:47.356
I don't go 15 minutes without hearing them. And it's really hard to explain
00:29:47.356 --> 00:29:50.176
to somebody that they need to take meds that are very sedating,
00:29:50.996 --> 00:29:57.236
when they don't understand or don't think that the meds are helping them through the entire thing.
00:29:57.696 --> 00:30:01.816
So basically what it is, it's a major disruption in my life,
00:30:01.816 --> 00:30:05.036
and it's a major distraction for me to do.
00:30:05.036 --> 00:30:14.816
I do, and I can't reach my full potential when I have this issue with being schizophrenic. Yeah.
00:30:16.276 --> 00:30:20.916
So, Daniel, did you know or have a sense when you were growing up that you were
00:30:20.916 --> 00:30:22.396
different than other children?
00:30:23.216 --> 00:30:26.496
I always did. And if you did, how did that make you feel?
00:30:27.196 --> 00:30:33.356
You know, I always knew that I was different from when I was a kid.
00:30:33.356 --> 00:30:39.136
I always knew I was different, and I prefer to be different.
00:30:39.316 --> 00:30:41.676
Some people are just different. I'm not like everybody else.
00:30:42.016 --> 00:30:46.236
That was to begin with, but then my tribulations begun, and I'm not.
00:30:46.809 --> 00:30:49.689
That's something that's actually similar to other people. Like,
00:30:49.969 --> 00:30:53.549
I'm different myself, but if I meet other people who hear voices,
00:30:53.869 --> 00:30:55.729
I'm, like, similar to them in that way.
00:30:56.189 --> 00:31:01.529
You know, me and other schizophrenics, we share the same symptoms,
00:31:01.769 --> 00:31:08.229
yet our personalities and, you know, the way we are internally are different.
00:31:09.169 --> 00:31:11.929
So, yeah, I was different ever since I was a kid. Yeah.
00:31:13.129 --> 00:31:19.269
What did you do? tell us some of the things that you did to help help you cope
00:31:19.269 --> 00:31:28.209
with with this illness yes to cope with this illness i had ever since a few
00:31:28.209 --> 00:31:30.149
years after i developed this illness.
00:31:31.729 --> 00:31:35.089
I started doing things to ignore
00:31:35.089 --> 00:31:37.949
my visual and auditory hallucinations because they
00:31:37.949 --> 00:31:41.149
were unrelenting and they were abusive at first i used
00:31:41.149 --> 00:31:44.849
to like bounce a tennis ball i used to chew gum you
00:31:44.849 --> 00:31:47.509
know i used to turn music up i used to
00:31:47.509 --> 00:31:51.269
do all that to ignore my symptoms and then i
00:31:51.269 --> 00:31:54.789
i got a job at home depot i was an essential worker during
00:31:54.789 --> 00:31:59.889
the covid crisis at home depot and what i was doing the work they had me there
00:31:59.889 --> 00:32:04.809
like stocking shelves and helping walking around doing all kinds of tasks all
00:32:04.809 --> 00:32:10.069
day long i think it worked it sorted out my brain because the voices are basically
00:32:10.069 --> 00:32:11.569
You know, my brain was firing,
00:32:11.789 --> 00:32:17.849
and I felt like it sorted out my brain, and the voices became more benevolent, actually.
00:32:18.289 --> 00:32:22.909
And ever since then, I hear them all day long, and I hallucinate all day long,
00:32:22.969 --> 00:32:26.629
but they're not abusive like they used to be. Yeah.
00:32:27.729 --> 00:32:32.249
So, Doc, there's a chapter in the book named after this quote from Daniel.
00:32:32.529 --> 00:32:38.029
It doesn't matter, Mom. I didn't go to school anyway. I only went to timeout.
00:32:38.029 --> 00:32:44.809
So this was the point where you and Daniel's father thought it was best for
00:32:44.809 --> 00:32:46.549
Daniel to be homeschooled.
00:32:46.629 --> 00:32:50.689
Was that demoralizing or a liberating moment?
00:32:51.706 --> 00:32:54.746
I think it was a very liberating moment, actually. Okay.
00:32:56.846 --> 00:33:01.926
Very liberating not to go to school. Finally not to go to school, even.
00:33:02.466 --> 00:33:09.286
And I learned at home. I had tutors, several different tutors,
00:33:09.326 --> 00:33:12.826
which were all very nice people and very helpful.
00:33:13.666 --> 00:33:18.406
And I did try to study at Tufts University for the GED.
00:33:19.486 --> 00:33:22.906
Eventually, I did go back to high school, and I did graduate at 18,
00:33:23.166 --> 00:33:24.966
and I never thought I would graduate.
00:33:25.206 --> 00:33:28.206
I thought I would graduate like at 30 years old. I managed to do it at 18.
00:33:29.660 --> 00:33:36.620
But when I went back to school, I was under, I was able to, you know,
00:33:36.680 --> 00:33:44.520
I didn't have these pre-diagnosis, which were like Tourette's syndrome, OCD, all that abated.
00:33:44.840 --> 00:33:48.500
And after I graduated from high school at age 19, at age 18,
00:33:48.700 --> 00:33:55.920
excuse me, I went to a halfway house for people that were in psychiatric units,
00:33:56.160 --> 00:33:59.780
and it's nearby, it was in Massachusetts,
00:34:00.400 --> 00:34:07.440
and living there, I then developed schizophrenia, and it was a disaster, it was unexpected.
00:34:07.480 --> 00:34:12.420
I never knew I would be hit with that disease in my life, and it was a shock
00:34:12.420 --> 00:34:18.020
to me and a lot of people that I became so mentally decrepitated,
00:34:18.300 --> 00:34:23.360
and I needed help, and I was in an environment where the help wasn't getting to me yet.
00:34:24.340 --> 00:34:28.900
Yeah. So, Mom, was it demoralizing and liberating for you?
00:34:29.940 --> 00:34:35.560
Well, it was both, because it was clearly the end of the traditional system,
00:34:36.300 --> 00:34:42.320
and setting up an alternative system at home had a lot of difficulties.
00:34:42.320 --> 00:34:46.700
There were a lot of challenges with it, and Danny eventually,
00:34:47.100 --> 00:34:53.780
as he mentioned, was in this residential facility, And that's when the schizophrenia,
00:34:54.080 --> 00:34:56.900
that's when the voices emerged, which we didn't know.
00:34:58.040 --> 00:35:03.820
Danny, you can talk about this, but Danny didn't talk about them much until
00:35:03.820 --> 00:35:10.640
he was somewhat older and until really the big hospitalization happened.
00:35:11.439 --> 00:35:16.479
In which the voices were very prominent and really took over.
00:35:17.099 --> 00:35:24.319
And that was a hard go. So it's like trappings of both.
00:35:24.499 --> 00:35:30.679
And being outside the traditional system doesn't necessarily give you a lot
00:35:30.679 --> 00:35:33.819
of confidence about what you're doing.
00:35:35.239 --> 00:35:41.039
But the workers that we had were, as Danny mentioned,
00:35:41.319 --> 00:35:48.619
were very empathic people who viewed Danny as a kid struggling to grow up rather
00:35:48.619 --> 00:35:50.299
than a diagnostic label.
00:35:51.059 --> 00:35:53.079
That makes a big difference.
00:35:54.759 --> 00:35:59.519
Danny, did you want to add something to that? Not as of yet. Okay. All right.
00:36:00.279 --> 00:36:04.599
So, Danny, let me ask you this. How did your time at side-by-side assist you
00:36:04.599 --> 00:36:06.139
in being more productive?
00:36:07.419 --> 00:36:12.619
And also, you found this thing called Hearing Voices Network.
00:36:12.879 --> 00:36:18.859
So how did those two things help you better cope?
00:36:19.519 --> 00:36:25.379
I felt like side-by-side was a trial period before seeing if I could live more
00:36:25.379 --> 00:36:27.799
independently than I got to live at side-by-side.
00:36:29.419 --> 00:36:36.939
And so, at Side by Side, you know, keeping busy, you know, not busier than I
00:36:36.939 --> 00:36:39.779
can handle these days, but it's always been with me.
00:36:40.059 --> 00:36:43.479
Keeping busy enough but not busier than I can handle has always been one of
00:36:43.479 --> 00:36:46.419
my objectives, is to remain somewhat busy.
00:36:47.519 --> 00:36:48.939
And that's basically...
00:36:50.095 --> 00:36:53.935
Part of my treatment is actually making sure that I have something to do and
00:36:53.935 --> 00:36:57.075
not just sitting around all day listening to voices and paying attention to
00:36:57.075 --> 00:37:01.155
my hallucinations all day because that's not productive at all.
00:37:01.595 --> 00:37:10.535
But also the grounds for your movement after that into independent living. Right.
00:37:11.355 --> 00:37:17.715
Which made a huge difference. You're right. You go from phase one to phase two to phase three.
00:37:18.415 --> 00:37:23.555
You don't go from phase one to phase three during recovery. It's just that way.
00:37:23.795 --> 00:37:31.775
So I felt like being hospitalized was like phase one, side by side.
00:37:32.155 --> 00:37:36.775
Then eventually I came around to side by side phase two, phase three. I live on my own.
00:37:37.375 --> 00:37:41.875
Before I went to side by side, after I had gotten out of the psych unit,
00:37:42.195 --> 00:37:46.295
I was in Cape Cod and I had a job working at a plant nursery.
00:37:46.875 --> 00:37:51.055
And I liked it a lot but me being under the microscope,
00:37:52.035 --> 00:37:56.495
finally it was sort of decided that I could use a little more care for a while
00:37:56.495 --> 00:38:03.455
and a little more attention for a while before moving on so I felt like like I said before,
00:38:03.675 --> 00:38:09.315
some of this for me has been like one step forward and two steps back but then
00:38:09.315 --> 00:38:12.075
it goes forward again it's just you know.
00:38:13.915 --> 00:38:17.175
It's just not a straight shot To my goals.
00:38:17.335 --> 00:38:21.415
It's not, it's not, it's a, it's a pretty, it's a crooked road to my goals.
00:38:21.795 --> 00:38:23.775
Out of state. Yeah.
00:38:24.735 --> 00:38:28.135
Um, what'd you say? Crooked mile. Yeah.
00:38:29.435 --> 00:38:36.855
Okay. So this lady named Tamara Hill had written a book called Mental Health
00:38:36.855 --> 00:38:38.915
in a Failed American System.
00:38:39.055 --> 00:38:44.655
And she said, the presuming social view that mental health is not as serious
00:38:44.655 --> 00:38:46.975
as the media says it is, blots progress.
00:38:47.675 --> 00:38:53.795
So this is for Dr. Ellen. Do you feel that the media plays a part in how we
00:38:53.795 --> 00:38:57.695
view and deal with mental illness? You bet it does.
00:38:57.995 --> 00:39:03.375
Yes, it's seen very pejoratively. It's seen very negatively.
00:39:04.415 --> 00:39:08.315
It's portrayed in very strange ways.
00:39:08.595 --> 00:39:14.575
It has a lot of the trappings of the old views of serious mental illness.
00:39:15.395 --> 00:39:21.635
And it's focused now much more on anxiety and depression in the kids.
00:39:21.935 --> 00:39:28.475
So it has stayed away from, I think, one of the major groups that needs to be
00:39:28.475 --> 00:39:33.075
attended to, which are people with serious mental illness with the big disorders
00:39:33.075 --> 00:39:34.995
that interrupt their lives.
00:39:35.435 --> 00:39:39.855
And the government has, by and large, stayed away from that.
00:39:40.355 --> 00:39:47.135
And now it feels hopeless. It's in the private sector, mainly. Yeah.
00:39:47.895 --> 00:39:52.875
You wrote, Dr. Ellen, in the book, history has taught us that neither the hospital
00:39:52.875 --> 00:39:57.215
nor the community are inherently more humane,
00:39:57.375 --> 00:40:02.895
but rather that social justice issues and civil rights must be combined with
00:40:02.895 --> 00:40:07.595
moral treatment and recovery approaches. Expound on that for us.
00:40:08.667 --> 00:40:17.967
Well, there's a huge amount of stigma, prejudice, distinctions among social groups.
00:40:18.647 --> 00:40:21.507
There's, I think, a lot of racism in it.
00:40:21.987 --> 00:40:25.867
It's because the resources are so limited.
00:40:26.267 --> 00:40:31.267
There are large groups of people who are excluded. They're not taken care of.
00:40:31.647 --> 00:40:38.447
And our society doesn't seem to feel that they need to do it.
00:40:38.667 --> 00:40:42.687
I mean, if you take a look at the school shootings, you'd come away thinking
00:40:42.687 --> 00:40:46.507
that they're done by people with serious mental illness.
00:40:47.067 --> 00:40:49.267
Statistically, that's completely untrue.
00:40:49.927 --> 00:40:57.647
And there's so many misconceptions, and there has been historically, about mental illness.
00:40:57.947 --> 00:41:03.287
There are pejorative terms, and people are afraid also.
00:41:04.553 --> 00:41:13.233
They're very fearful of the major disorders, and they really can disrupt completely people's lives.
00:41:14.953 --> 00:41:21.373
The media doesn't portray it realistically when they portray it,
00:41:21.493 --> 00:41:26.593
and most of the time, they don't. It's a non-issue right now.
00:41:26.813 --> 00:41:31.973
The largest percentage of homeless people now are homeless families.
00:41:31.973 --> 00:41:36.273
The largest number of people in homeless families are children,
00:41:36.593 --> 00:41:37.953
six years old and younger.
00:41:38.473 --> 00:41:45.113
And there's no, I haven't seen anything in the media about that group.
00:41:45.453 --> 00:41:52.173
And it's a huge group now. And they're young mothers with little kids,
00:41:52.593 --> 00:42:02.093
many of whom are DV survivors or have traumatic histories and completely ignored.
00:42:02.373 --> 00:42:09.613
And the media, you know, focuses on what happens at the encampments and anything that's sensational.
00:42:09.853 --> 00:42:12.233
They sensationalize mental illness.
00:42:12.873 --> 00:42:18.933
Yeah. And then the other piece is what they, this thing called Penrose Law,
00:42:19.173 --> 00:42:24.753
which suggests that there's the inverse correlation between psychiatric beds
00:42:24.753 --> 00:42:25.973
and prison populations.
00:42:25.973 --> 00:42:32.073
So as mental health hospitals close, incarceration rates increase.
00:42:32.573 --> 00:42:42.633
And you can say homelessness as well because, you know, a lot of those, a lot of people.
00:42:43.293 --> 00:42:49.013
They're not going to be given the opportunity like Daniel and be allowed to
00:42:49.013 --> 00:42:53.773
have housing and all that stuff. So, yeah.
00:42:54.473 --> 00:42:58.893
So let me let me say let me ask you this question so we can kind of close it out.
00:42:59.493 --> 00:43:05.553
Besides reading your book, what can be done to increase advocacy towards mental
00:43:05.553 --> 00:43:08.833
health and diminish the stigma associated with it?
00:43:09.784 --> 00:43:15.544
Well, I think one of the groups that needs to be appealed to are parents of
00:43:15.544 --> 00:43:18.984
kids with mental health issues of any kind.
00:43:19.484 --> 00:43:22.724
And I think they need to become advocates.
00:43:23.004 --> 00:43:28.224
They need to protect their kids. They need to accept the fact that their kids
00:43:28.224 --> 00:43:32.824
may be different. So what? everybody's different in different ways.
00:43:33.544 --> 00:43:42.604
There needs to be a lot of press about the realities, mental illness, and there isn't.
00:43:43.064 --> 00:43:47.544
It's just sensational distortions from what I can tell.
00:43:47.864 --> 00:43:56.044
So I think a huge amount has to be done because the stigma is huge and it remains.
00:43:56.524 --> 00:44:03.564
And unfortunately, the more vulnerable groups are people who are poorly resourced.
00:44:04.761 --> 00:44:09.401
And, I mean, that's always true, and it's particularly true in this country. Yeah.
00:44:10.001 --> 00:44:15.081
So, Daniel, what advice would you give young people that are struggling with mental health issues?
00:44:15.961 --> 00:44:20.101
Struggling with mental health issues is to get treatment.
00:44:20.241 --> 00:44:25.981
If you can't afford treatment, there are places that there's hotlines you can call.
00:44:26.161 --> 00:44:30.461
There's places like, you know, I worked at a place called Webster House.
00:44:30.461 --> 00:44:35.261
It was a day place for people with psychiatric problems, psychological problems.
00:44:35.541 --> 00:44:39.941
You know, I worked in the kitchen there. It's free. They can come there and
00:44:39.941 --> 00:44:46.521
be amongst that community and then begin their self-work as well as, you know,
00:44:46.661 --> 00:44:51.741
have their self-work augmented by all the people that are available.
00:44:51.961 --> 00:44:55.181
There's always something available to get treatment in some way,
00:44:55.181 --> 00:44:58.941
you know, that doesn't cost a lot of money.
00:44:59.061 --> 00:45:04.181
There's day places to go. There's groups you can join, virtual ones online and
00:45:04.181 --> 00:45:08.261
in person, and you should reach out and try that.
00:45:08.461 --> 00:45:16.281
And the supports are critical for both the target patient and the families.
00:45:17.958 --> 00:45:25.778
Yeah. So I'm asking all of my guests this question or giving them this challenge,
00:45:25.798 --> 00:45:26.778
however you want to look at it.
00:45:27.178 --> 00:45:30.298
I need you to finish this sentence.
00:45:30.998 --> 00:45:36.958
And if both of y'all can do it or just want it, it doesn't matter. I have hope because.
00:45:39.438 --> 00:45:45.678
Okay. Answer that, Danny. I am not 100% hopeful all the time.
00:45:45.678 --> 00:45:48.558
You know, I have hope because I'm still alive.
00:45:49.418 --> 00:45:53.178
Is that good? Hey, that's your answer. That's great.
00:45:54.658 --> 00:46:06.318
That's my answer. And I suppose the general arc of history is towards justice and care.
00:46:06.998 --> 00:46:12.338
But, boy, in these times, it's really been challenged.
00:46:12.998 --> 00:46:21.958
Yeah. There's so much going on that is very offensive and particularly,
00:46:21.978 --> 00:46:27.598
I mean, it's for everybody, but the groups we deal with are targeted.
00:46:28.178 --> 00:46:34.158
Yeah. So hopefully now that we've gone through the interview, you kind of understand.
00:46:35.576 --> 00:46:41.796
How I responded to the book because as somebody that's been an elected official
00:46:41.796 --> 00:46:48.516
and somebody has been an advocate for more funding at the government level for
00:46:48.516 --> 00:46:52.576
mental health and pushing for awareness,
00:46:53.596 --> 00:47:01.536
it frustrates me that somebody who not only has been a professional in the field,
00:47:01.596 --> 00:47:05.596
but also has a personal experience with it,
00:47:05.996 --> 00:47:10.616
is just the hoops that you've had to go through, the struggles.
00:47:11.776 --> 00:47:19.736
When Daniel talks about his experience at Manville, he said he was manhandled
00:47:19.736 --> 00:47:25.416
instead of just, like I said, as a parent myself,
00:47:26.336 --> 00:47:29.556
that described me crazy.
00:47:29.556 --> 00:47:32.976
And nuts and just, you know, want to lash out.
00:47:33.136 --> 00:47:38.116
But the way that you handled it, and I know you had frustrations and stuff because
00:47:38.116 --> 00:47:39.136
you reveal that in the book,
00:47:39.196 --> 00:47:45.256
but the way that you handled it gives hope that there is a way that you can
00:47:45.256 --> 00:47:49.516
channel that anger and frustration and do something constructive.
00:47:50.396 --> 00:47:54.216
And, you know, when I look at Daniel in this interview, you know,
00:47:54.376 --> 00:48:04.436
I can see the love and the end result of the consideration and care that you put into him,
00:48:05.416 --> 00:48:09.096
to have as normal a life as he could have.
00:48:09.936 --> 00:48:16.576
And Daniel, I will say to you that you are, your answer was correct.
00:48:17.276 --> 00:48:22.996
It's like because you are alive and because you are still working through it,
00:48:22.996 --> 00:48:30.216
it's an inspiration and it's very hopeful to me and hopefully it'll be hopeful for others as well.
00:48:31.894 --> 00:48:34.834
Go ahead, Doc. I'm sorry. Well, we hope so.
00:48:35.034 --> 00:48:40.594
That was the reason for writing the book, that other families could benefit by our experience.
00:48:40.874 --> 00:48:45.714
I feel that very likely never to live a completely normal life,
00:48:45.834 --> 00:48:47.494
but I can live a good life.
00:48:48.174 --> 00:48:51.274
You know, I can help other people live good lives, even if they can't live normal
00:48:51.274 --> 00:48:53.734
lives because of their conditions.
00:48:54.734 --> 00:49:00.754
Yeah. All right. So how can people get this book? How can people reach out to either one of y'all?
00:49:01.054 --> 00:49:02.974
Go ahead and take the time to do that.
00:49:03.994 --> 00:49:07.694
Amazon. Amazon has a whole stack of them.
00:49:08.034 --> 00:49:11.494
Yeah, they've been selling out on Amazon. Yeah, they've been selling,
00:49:11.714 --> 00:49:14.614
it looks like, I think fairly well.
00:49:15.274 --> 00:49:20.634
And the reviews have been very good. But Amazon is the most successful.
00:49:21.114 --> 00:49:24.714
The big booksellers all have the book. Okay.
00:49:25.714 --> 00:49:28.794
It's readily accessible. I went to the bookstore.
00:49:28.994 --> 00:49:31.814
It's not on the shelf at the bookstore yet, but it is online,
00:49:32.034 --> 00:49:34.254
available online, and it's selling out quick.
00:49:35.114 --> 00:49:43.274
Okay. Well, Dr. Ellen Bassuk and Daniel Schoonover, I really appreciate you taking
00:49:43.274 --> 00:49:46.994
the time not only to write the book, but to come on the podcast.
00:49:47.854 --> 00:49:51.314
And I do this for all my guests.
00:49:51.554 --> 00:49:56.114
If you have, now that you've been on, you have an open invitation to come back.
00:49:56.114 --> 00:50:00.754
If there's some issues that you think that need to be addressed and you need
00:50:00.754 --> 00:50:09.814
a platform, feel free to come on and we'll reach out to B and we'll make sure that we'll get you on.
00:50:10.174 --> 00:50:13.854
But I greatly appreciate y'all coming on and talking about this.
00:50:14.174 --> 00:50:17.634
And thank you for inviting us. Yes. Enjoyed talking to you.
00:50:18.294 --> 00:50:20.734
All right, guys. And we're going to catch y'all on the other side.
00:50:41.527 --> 00:50:45.847
Time for our next guest, Susanne Antonetta.
00:50:46.807 --> 00:50:53.087
Susanne Paola Antonetta is the author of The Terrible Unlikelihood of Our Being
00:50:53.087 --> 00:50:57.807
Here and numerous other works of non-fiction, fiction, and poetry.
00:50:58.147 --> 00:51:03.347
Her accolades include a New York Times Notable Book, an American Book Award,
00:51:03.827 --> 00:51:06.847
a Library Journal Best Science Book, and others.
00:51:07.167 --> 00:51:14.087
She writes for Psychology Today, the New York Times, Ms., The Huffington Post,
00:51:14.287 --> 00:51:20.687
The UK Independent, The Hill, Orion, and The New Republic, and has been featured on CNN.
00:51:21.127 --> 00:51:26.167
She lives in Asheville, North Carolina. Her new book is The Devil's Castle,
00:51:26.527 --> 00:51:33.147
Nazi Eugenics, Euthanasia, and How Psychiatry's Troubled History Reverberates Today.
00:51:33.327 --> 00:51:37.607
And we are going to get into that book during the interview.
00:51:37.787 --> 00:51:41.587
So ladies and gentlemen, it is my distinct honor and privilege to have as a
00:51:41.587 --> 00:51:45.607
guest on this podcast, Susanne Antonetta.
00:51:58.649 --> 00:52:03.049
How are you doing, ma'am? You doing good? I'm doing well. It's a beautiful day
00:52:03.049 --> 00:52:05.229
here in North Carolina, so I'm good.
00:52:05.749 --> 00:52:11.189
Yeah, well, you're not that far from me. I'm in Atlanta. And so, yeah, it's nice out.
00:52:11.549 --> 00:52:16.929
Of course, they got the burn warnings going on, so... Sure, sure.
00:52:17.189 --> 00:52:19.289
Trying to make sure people don't start no fires.
00:52:20.249 --> 00:52:26.149
But other than that, I like warm weather, so I don't mind it at all.
00:52:26.149 --> 00:52:29.289
It doesn't matter what time of year it is, as long as it's warm, I'm good.
00:52:29.709 --> 00:52:34.489
So we're going to talk about your book, The Devil's Castle.
00:52:35.809 --> 00:52:40.489
And I found it very, very informative. Thank you.
00:52:41.149 --> 00:52:45.009
And, you know, and how you got your point across.
00:52:45.449 --> 00:52:48.749
And so we won't be able to, because I want people to read the book.
00:52:48.869 --> 00:52:52.269
So I won't, we'll just be scratching the surface with the questions.
00:52:52.909 --> 00:52:55.909
But you put a lot into it, I could tell.
00:52:56.149 --> 00:53:01.189
Sure. I did. Yes, I did. Yeah. And that'll come out in the interview as well.
00:53:01.369 --> 00:53:07.149
So what I want to do is start it off. And normally, I try to pull a quote to
00:53:07.149 --> 00:53:08.689
kind of get the conversation started.
00:53:09.229 --> 00:53:15.609
But what I decided to do with you was to pull an excerpt from the book to get you to respond to this.
00:53:16.069 --> 00:53:22.249
I would love that. All right. So when I was 12, I wrote in my diary that life
00:53:22.249 --> 00:53:30.649
was a sort of play and humans were characters wearing garments of such complexity and intricacy.
00:53:30.829 --> 00:53:35.009
It dazzles the one who is slow enough to think about it.
00:53:35.955 --> 00:53:39.995
Slowness to think about it, I indicated, was not normal.
00:53:40.175 --> 00:53:43.975
To be slow enough was to allow your brain to break the rules.
00:53:44.095 --> 00:53:49.275
I felt then that I could do this, and my difference let those garments.
00:53:49.675 --> 00:53:54.955
I think, young as I was, I chose a word to have more magic than clothing.
00:53:55.635 --> 00:54:00.095
Dazzle. I don't know how I appeared to others as I watched those garments.
00:54:00.275 --> 00:54:05.695
I imagined I seemed socially awkward, but this is the version of the story I
00:54:05.695 --> 00:54:07.915
want to live. Talk to me about that quote.
00:54:09.056 --> 00:54:12.576
Sure, absolutely. Well, just to give people listening an overview,
00:54:12.816 --> 00:54:16.576
since they won't be familiar with the book, it talks about what happened in
00:54:16.576 --> 00:54:22.536
Germany leading up to World War II and during World War II, where they actually eliminated,
00:54:22.956 --> 00:54:27.136
killed in gas chambers, a large number of their psychiatric population.
00:54:27.756 --> 00:54:31.636
The total would probably be in all the territories they were occupying in Germany
00:54:31.636 --> 00:54:34.676
itself, two to three hundred thousand people.
00:54:35.456 --> 00:54:41.576
So, and the gas chambers were actually developed for people with psychiatric diagnoses.
00:54:42.056 --> 00:54:45.236
And one of the things I'm arguing is that we are getting to the point where
00:54:45.236 --> 00:54:48.516
we're medicalizing humanity, we're medicalizing everything.
00:54:49.196 --> 00:54:54.216
And that for many of us, you know, I'm very neurodiverse, simply existing as
00:54:54.216 --> 00:55:01.376
who we are can work with support rather than medicalizing, rather than medicating.
00:55:01.576 --> 00:55:06.236
And as the book goes on to discuss in the United States, and I go to the post-war
00:55:06.236 --> 00:55:12.076
period, that medicalizing was actually turned against things like women in menopause,
00:55:12.116 --> 00:55:14.876
and something that I write about quite extensively,
00:55:15.376 --> 00:55:19.396
the anger of Black protesters in the 1960s.
00:55:19.676 --> 00:55:24.356
They're actually psychiatrists suggesting that It was something called discontrol
00:55:24.356 --> 00:55:30.736
syndrome that caused people to, we call them race riots, I call them protests,
00:55:31.116 --> 00:55:37.896
that caused this to happen and that it should be fixed by brain manipulation, not social justice.
00:55:38.856 --> 00:55:44.876
So in using my own story, I think I'm really arguing for let's look at what
00:55:44.876 --> 00:55:49.156
we are doing, how we're thinking about the mind, and let's look at it differently.
00:55:49.716 --> 00:55:53.896
Okay. So now the next icebreaker is what I call 20 questions.
00:55:54.596 --> 00:56:01.196
Sure. So I need you to give me a number between 1 and 20. Oh, let's say 8. Okay.
00:56:01.736 --> 00:56:07.896
What is one thing you hope the current administration will do or not do during this term?
00:56:09.353 --> 00:56:13.933
Oh, my Lord, getting that down to one thing. Can I say just stop?
00:56:14.233 --> 00:56:19.073
I'm going to say just stop and leave it at that. Okay, that'll be good.
00:56:19.673 --> 00:56:25.373
All right. So what led you to write this book and how did you come about the title?
00:56:26.313 --> 00:56:30.393
Well, the title comes from one of my kind of positive characters.
00:56:30.653 --> 00:56:34.973
There's several historical characters in there. And one was a German judge named
00:56:34.973 --> 00:56:38.453
Paul Schraber who was committed for life.
00:56:39.033 --> 00:56:42.793
And he was committed to an institution that would go on to become one of these
00:56:42.793 --> 00:56:46.593
gas chambers used by the Nazi euthanasia program.
00:56:47.013 --> 00:56:54.213
So in the late 1800s, he gets to this place, Sarnstein, where he's being forced to, you know, stay.
00:56:54.933 --> 00:56:59.913
And he said, oh, this is the devil's castle. And he kind of saw corpses there.
00:57:00.153 --> 00:57:05.333
So one of the things I write about is how much what we think of as neurodiversity
00:57:05.333 --> 00:57:09.493
is sometimes noticing things that are happening that maybe more neurotypical
00:57:09.493 --> 00:57:11.333
people just aren't picking up on.
00:57:11.713 --> 00:57:16.673
And when I started the book was learning about the Nazis, just this program
00:57:16.673 --> 00:57:18.873
to eliminate the mentally ill.
00:57:18.973 --> 00:57:23.713
I mean, I knew, and I don't like that phrase, but I'll use it for ease.
00:57:23.913 --> 00:57:28.433
I mean, I think we know now that they, you know, attack Jews,
00:57:28.733 --> 00:57:34.013
homosexuals, Roma, and Sinti peoples, But this, to me, was a story that had
00:57:34.013 --> 00:57:38.253
really been lost and was not widely known.
00:57:38.753 --> 00:57:45.093
It's not just that they did that, too, but that they started with the psychiatric population.
00:57:45.853 --> 00:57:50.993
And so many historians, like one I quote, Getzali, said, if people had gone
00:57:50.993 --> 00:57:56.293
out in Germany and protested, this action, which you could see them doing in
00:57:56.293 --> 00:57:58.913
the very early 40s before the war,
00:57:59.933 --> 00:58:03.593
Hitler would not have done what he did with the concentration camps.
00:58:03.653 --> 00:58:06.173
He would have known that he wasn't going to get away with it.
00:58:06.413 --> 00:58:10.453
So I wanted to tell that story because I think we're always kind of on some
00:58:10.453 --> 00:58:13.573
of those slippery slopes as a culture. Yeah.
00:58:14.647 --> 00:58:16.107
All right. Before we get too deep,
00:58:16.327 --> 00:58:21.807
I need you to define two things for the listeners. The first is eugenics.
00:58:22.507 --> 00:58:28.247
Sure. Eugenics was a theory that actually started in the late 1800s with a very
00:58:28.247 --> 00:58:32.647
odd cousin of Charles Darwin named Francis Galton.
00:58:33.107 --> 00:58:37.767
It literally means good genes, although at the time he didn't know what DNA was.
00:58:37.907 --> 00:58:43.887
But there were theories that there was kind of this genetic germplasm that is passed on.
00:58:44.147 --> 00:58:49.187
And, you know, it's kind of the belief that genes are everything and that you
00:58:49.187 --> 00:58:53.507
control the population by controlling who reproduces and how much they reproduce,
00:58:53.787 --> 00:58:59.347
whether you do that through eliminating a population so it cannot reproduce,
00:58:59.727 --> 00:59:06.327
segregating that population, or simply trying to keep birth rates down in certain populations.
00:59:07.553 --> 00:59:11.993
And we, I think, still live with a lot of eugenics in our cultural thinking.
00:59:13.073 --> 00:59:17.393
So that's one idea, that genes kind of shape us into who we are.
00:59:17.893 --> 00:59:22.773
And I want to throw in here that I just wrote a piece for Slate about Jeffrey Epstein.
00:59:22.933 --> 00:59:27.953
Jeffrey Epstein and his kind of crowd were very obsessed with genes and eugenics
00:59:27.953 --> 00:59:29.493
and genetic manipulation.
00:59:30.473 --> 00:59:35.833
So it is very much still here. And I think I answered part one and forgot part
00:59:35.833 --> 00:59:39.073
two, Erik. I'm so sorry. Was there another part to that question?
00:59:39.313 --> 00:59:41.233
Well, no, I hadn't asked part two yet, but.
00:59:41.493 --> 00:59:44.973
Oh, I'm sorry. Before we get to part two. I tend to do that. That's okay.
00:59:45.173 --> 00:59:51.733
But before we get to part two, you know, one of the things that you mentioned, Jeffrey Epstein.
00:59:52.013 --> 00:59:56.233
So a lot of people would say, oh, eugenics. Well, that's, that sounds like some
00:59:56.233 --> 00:59:57.433
kind of conservative thing.
00:59:57.433 --> 01:00:02.313
The history of the United States is that a lot of, quote unquote,
01:00:02.613 --> 01:00:08.273
liberals were into eugenics, especially in the early 20th century.
01:00:08.633 --> 01:00:12.953
And that was part of the argument why people were against climate change,
01:00:12.953 --> 01:00:15.893
because they were saying that was a form of eugenics, too.
01:00:16.393 --> 01:00:19.313
You know, population control, all that kind of stuff.
01:00:19.673 --> 01:00:26.033
So I wanted to lay that out because that's one of your arguments in the book.
01:00:26.033 --> 01:00:31.473
And then the other thing is the second part is explain what the DSM is.
01:00:32.436 --> 01:00:36.356
Sure, that's super important. So in the late 20th century,
01:00:37.076 --> 01:00:41.736
when psychiatry kind of felt like it needed to be more scientific and more like
01:00:41.736 --> 01:00:43.076
a real branch of medicine,
01:00:43.076 --> 01:00:49.476
they kind of took this very obscure book called The Diagnostic and Statistical
01:00:49.476 --> 01:00:56.496
Manual of Mental Disorders and revised it and made it central to our operations.
01:00:56.496 --> 01:00:59.916
I mean, you can't get insurance reimbursement if you're a doctor unless you
01:00:59.916 --> 01:01:02.056
give somebody a DSM diagnosis.
01:01:02.936 --> 01:01:06.996
And so it's really the beating heart of psychiatry in this country.
01:01:06.996 --> 01:01:09.276
And it's a very problematic document.
01:01:10.036 --> 01:01:14.176
So, yeah, it is important to understand what it is. And the point about liberals,
01:01:14.376 --> 01:01:15.616
you know, you're absolutely right.
01:01:15.816 --> 01:01:18.096
There was no right and left in that.
01:01:18.536 --> 01:01:25.436
In fact, lots of people we think of as, you know, very right-thinking people
01:01:25.436 --> 01:01:31.336
like Oliver Wendell Holmes were very into eugenics and a lot of millionaires.
01:01:31.336 --> 01:01:34.456
It's always kind of been, in some ways, a rich person's game.
01:01:34.976 --> 01:01:40.096
You know, the Harrimans, the Rockefellers, the Kelloggs were funding these clinics
01:01:40.096 --> 01:01:43.336
where they were doing eugenic research and...
01:01:44.417 --> 01:01:47.877
Of the things that always makes me smile a little bit ironically,
01:01:48.317 --> 01:01:54.977
can you smile ironically, is that my family spent a lot of time in the Pine Barrens of New Jersey.
01:01:55.277 --> 01:01:58.637
We had this kind of little shack that my grandfather built.
01:01:59.317 --> 01:02:02.497
And we would all go there and spend quite a bit of time there.
01:02:02.617 --> 01:02:09.577
And it was sort of this area notorious for supposed inbreeding and bad genetics.
01:02:09.957 --> 01:02:15.957
And so one of those sites, actually, the eugenics records office has file cards
01:02:15.957 --> 01:02:19.357
on all these families. And I like to think my family's in there.
01:02:20.517 --> 01:02:22.857
I can only hope. I don't know for sure.
01:02:24.097 --> 01:02:29.797
So yes, that was, and I think still is, you know, Jeffrey Epstein and his buds,
01:02:30.417 --> 01:02:35.037
you know, people like Noam Chomsky, they're very liberal. Larry Summers.
01:02:35.457 --> 01:02:38.877
But the things they were saying to each other in the emails were pretty awful
01:02:38.877 --> 01:02:44.657
about minority populations, about women, you know, very disturbing stuff.
01:02:44.657 --> 01:02:49.637
So I think that when you put that kind of like robe of science,
01:02:50.017 --> 01:02:55.117
that golden robe of science around something, people feel okay about having
01:02:55.117 --> 01:03:01.417
thoughts that are pretty despicable. Yeah.
01:03:02.337 --> 01:03:09.417
So like you said in your opening answer to the quote that you put your story
01:03:09.417 --> 01:03:14.697
in this book, it could have been just strictly a research book,
01:03:14.977 --> 01:03:18.537
but you interwove a lot of your personal stuff.
01:03:18.757 --> 01:03:24.637
So you revealed to us that you have been diagnosed with schizophrenia and bipolar disorder.
01:03:25.666 --> 01:03:31.046
How has that been a challenge for you in life and in the process, writing this book?
01:03:32.346 --> 01:03:36.606
I do reveal that. The diagnosis was changed ultimately to bipolar.
01:03:36.606 --> 01:03:39.886
But yes, I was diagnosed as schizophrenic when I was a teenager.
01:03:39.886 --> 01:03:41.346
I was given shock treatment.
01:03:41.546 --> 01:03:43.566
It was pretty horrendous.
01:03:44.846 --> 01:03:48.686
And, you know, it was actually kind of controversial even among,
01:03:49.006 --> 01:03:53.526
like, my literary agent, people that I work with, to put so much of myself in
01:03:53.526 --> 01:03:58.406
there. And I want to say now that so much of myself is maybe 10 to 15 percent of the book.
01:03:58.626 --> 01:04:01.046
It's not a memoir by any stretch.
01:04:01.786 --> 01:04:08.986
But to me, it's just, you know, whenever I would read these stories about euthanasia
01:04:08.986 --> 01:04:11.346
and the Nazi Operation T4,
01:04:11.586 --> 01:04:15.286
which was the one that was conducted in the gas chambers, there were six of
01:04:15.286 --> 01:04:18.426
them for this action, this project.
01:04:18.426 --> 01:04:24.706
You know, it would always be people from such a distance trying to imagine what
01:04:24.706 --> 01:04:28.886
the people involved felt, but clearly unable to do that.
01:04:29.446 --> 01:04:33.466
And I think the fact that I could have been a victim, that family members could
01:04:33.466 --> 01:04:36.786
have been victims, was just really essential.
01:04:36.786 --> 01:04:42.326
I think that I needed to be in there as somebody with a stake in it and who
01:04:42.326 --> 01:04:48.966
had witnessed a lot of the late 20th century psychiatry here in the United States
01:04:48.966 --> 01:04:51.826
and witnessed a lot of what really went off the rails there, too.
01:04:52.326 --> 01:04:58.546
So, yeah, that was important to me to do. So, my previous guest...
01:04:59.461 --> 01:05:06.401
He was also diagnosed with schizophrenia, and he felt that the illness denied
01:05:06.401 --> 01:05:09.121
him an opportunity to be at his full potential.
01:05:09.641 --> 01:05:11.741
Sure. Do you feel that same way?
01:05:12.401 --> 01:05:17.421
I wouldn't exactly say that, but I think, for one thing, schizophrenia,
01:05:17.881 --> 01:05:22.561
there's overwhelming evidence, including a study that was done by a man who
01:05:22.561 --> 01:05:25.921
headed the Schizophrenia Project at the National Institutes of Health,
01:05:26.221 --> 01:05:31.361
so Lauren Mosher, that proved that schizophrenics do much better if they are
01:05:31.361 --> 01:05:35.581
not medicated in their first break, if you can stay off medication.
01:05:35.981 --> 01:05:40.741
And one of the two subjects of my book, Dorothea Buck, was schizophrenic.
01:05:40.821 --> 01:05:45.521
And so she writes a lot about schizophrenia, about how she was treated.
01:05:46.041 --> 01:05:51.321
She was sterilized by the Nazis at the age of 19 because Hitler wanted schizophrenia
01:05:51.321 --> 01:05:55.841
out of the population, so he sterilized and killed schizophrenics.
01:05:56.501 --> 01:06:01.581
And she came up with an alternative way to treat it that actually was very effective.
01:06:02.101 --> 01:06:05.801
So one answer is that I think that you have to make sure that what's limiting
01:06:05.801 --> 01:06:07.741
you is not the treatment, but the.
01:06:08.814 --> 01:06:12.714
Problem itself or the mental state itself. And, you know, of course,
01:06:13.034 --> 01:06:19.914
yes, I do do some things to manage my bipolar, or I would have a reduced life.
01:06:19.914 --> 01:06:22.634
And when people say that to me, I understand it.
01:06:22.914 --> 01:06:27.214
I'm sure for them it's completely true, because for many people it's completely true.
01:06:27.774 --> 01:06:32.554
I would just say that we have never tried on a large scale the things that have
01:06:32.554 --> 01:06:33.874
been shown to really work.
01:06:34.034 --> 01:06:40.234
And I think that's as sad as hearing that someone feels that their lives have been limited.
01:06:41.054 --> 01:06:48.514
Yeah. All right. So many regard Emil Kraepelin, I think I'm saying the name right.
01:06:48.894 --> 01:06:54.674
Yeah. As the father of modern psychology, but your book does not put him in a positive light.
01:06:55.194 --> 01:07:00.474
Explain why. No. He was an anti-Semite. He was an extreme anti-Semite.
01:07:00.814 --> 01:07:05.514
And the head of the a euthanasia program, and the worst of the Nazi doctors,
01:07:05.534 --> 01:07:10.334
who also worked at the camps with Jewish populations, had been trained by him.
01:07:10.554 --> 01:07:16.534
The Nuremberg Race Law of 1933, which eliminated Jews, eliminated jobs,
01:07:16.694 --> 01:07:21.374
eliminated citizenship, really reduced their status, was crafted by his students,
01:07:21.394 --> 01:07:22.834
and they said it was in his honor.
01:07:23.374 --> 01:07:30.014
So he was a bad guy. We do practice Krapelinian psychiatry.
01:07:30.014 --> 01:07:34.894
Our DSM was created by a group who called themselves Neo-Krapelinians,
01:07:35.034 --> 01:07:40.634
and I think we need to get that error out of our system because Krapelin was
01:07:40.634 --> 01:07:42.154
not working to help people.
01:07:42.294 --> 01:07:45.294
He was not working out of a sense of compassion and care.
01:07:45.494 --> 01:07:51.074
He felt like the psychiatrist's main duty was to his government and his state
01:07:51.074 --> 01:07:53.754
and to cleanse the population.
01:07:53.754 --> 01:07:58.074
So his categories, which we use, he identified schizophrenia,
01:07:58.334 --> 01:08:02.114
bipolar, and other things, were not created to help people.
01:08:02.254 --> 01:08:08.114
They were created to assign value to people. And I think we need a very clear
01:08:08.114 --> 01:08:09.934
acknowledgement of that fact.
01:08:12.379 --> 01:08:19.719
You mentioned Dorothea Buck and Paul Schreiber. Why were these individuals important
01:08:19.719 --> 01:08:22.499
for you to include their stories in the book?
01:08:23.119 --> 01:08:27.099
They're just both really heroic. Buck actually lived to be 102.
01:08:27.899 --> 01:08:32.459
So she was sterilized by the Nazis. You know, her life was really destroyed.
01:08:32.719 --> 01:08:37.279
Sterilized Germans could not work or go to college. They couldn't work at high-level jobs.
01:08:37.859 --> 01:08:42.859
And she became an activist. I mean, she was protesting well into her 90s,
01:08:42.959 --> 01:08:47.779
demanding the government acknowledge what they had done to the psychiatric population.
01:08:48.639 --> 01:08:51.839
Schreber, as I mentioned, was a judge committed for life.
01:08:52.499 --> 01:08:57.419
And he represented himself and got himself out.
01:08:57.659 --> 01:09:01.919
And his filings, his court filings were so powerful. He got out,
01:09:02.039 --> 01:09:06.439
I think, in 1903 that they changed German law.
01:09:06.939 --> 01:09:09.759
And he didn't say there's nothing you know i'm just
01:09:09.759 --> 01:09:12.719
as normal as you are and that's why you should let me out he said i've
01:09:12.719 --> 01:09:16.359
had profound religious experiences and you damn well
01:09:16.359 --> 01:09:19.259
better recognize that something real is going on in what
01:09:19.259 --> 01:09:23.939
is happening in my brain and the court actually agreed with him and sort of
01:09:23.939 --> 01:09:29.839
mocked his doctor in a very interesting way so to me they're heroes but you
01:09:29.839 --> 01:09:34.259
know there's so many heroes i was you know i told the story of these three doctors
01:09:34.259 --> 01:09:36.779
who believed that, well, it's,
01:09:37.352 --> 01:09:41.212
Many other people came to believe it, but they kind of started this idea that
01:09:41.212 --> 01:09:46.512
Black protesters were suffering from this brain injury, this discontrol syndrome,
01:09:46.752 --> 01:09:52.272
and should be treated with electrodes, right? Just horrendous.
01:09:52.472 --> 01:10:00.652
This amazing guy wrote a piece for Ebony Magazine in 1973 saying this is going
01:10:00.652 --> 01:10:05.652
into the population and targeting Blacks and trying to manipulate their brains.
01:10:05.652 --> 01:10:09.712
And I mean, I guess what I'm saying is that these people come up in my story
01:10:09.712 --> 01:10:14.332
who are so heroic that it balances it out in some ways.
01:10:14.552 --> 01:10:20.852
And so Buck and Schaber were really important because they're such a great counterweight. Yeah.
01:10:21.632 --> 01:10:26.972
All right. In the book, you stated that those diagnosed with a major medical,
01:10:27.412 --> 01:10:30.132
a major mental disorder in the U.S.
01:10:30.232 --> 01:10:35.452
Have a life expectancy 20 to 30 years shorter than those who aren't diagnosed.
01:10:35.652 --> 01:10:39.012
Part of the loss of life lies in how they're medicated.
01:10:39.392 --> 01:10:44.112
One in four jailed individuals in the U.S. is in a psychiatric crisis.
01:10:44.872 --> 01:10:51.532
One-fifth of police shootings involve psychiatric episodes. Most are harmless.
01:10:51.952 --> 01:10:57.332
Is this a fair assessment of the degree of mental misery in this country?
01:10:57.772 --> 01:11:02.632
It's a very fair assessment, and I'll sort of punctuate that by saying that
01:11:02.632 --> 01:11:06.432
some of those thoughts come from Alan Francis, who's one of the most prominent
01:11:06.432 --> 01:11:07.912
psychiatrists in this country.
01:11:08.012 --> 01:11:13.612
He actually led the revision of the DSM, the DSM-IV, and, you know,
01:11:13.672 --> 01:11:18.852
just an amazingly prominent guy. And what he says is that the biggest psych
01:11:18.852 --> 01:11:20.652
hospital in the U.S. now is the L.A.
01:11:20.792 --> 01:11:27.972
County Jail, and he's quite correct in that. We are just allowing people to suffer.
01:11:28.032 --> 01:11:29.872
We're allowing people to...
01:11:31.195 --> 01:11:34.635
Fall through the cracks. And it's really tragic.
01:11:34.955 --> 01:11:38.915
And yeah, there are many, many awful police shootings. There are often people
01:11:38.915 --> 01:11:40.935
of color who also have a diagnosis.
01:11:41.755 --> 01:11:47.595
There was a black autistic teenager killed when police actually followed his
01:11:47.595 --> 01:11:51.455
car home over a very minor car stop. He ended up being shot.
01:11:51.595 --> 01:11:55.575
It's just, yeah, I mean, I could go on. But yes, it's, it's,
01:11:55.755 --> 01:11:58.875
we are in a state, I think, of crisis.
01:11:59.335 --> 01:12:02.955
I don't know how else to put it. So much of the population is suffering.
01:12:03.355 --> 01:12:08.655
Yeah. And, you know, I have a background not only in politics, but in law enforcement.
01:12:08.895 --> 01:12:14.875
And so a lot of times, and most of my law enforcement was, you know, in the jails.
01:12:15.515 --> 01:12:19.995
And so, you know, I could testify to that.
01:12:21.310 --> 01:12:27.270
Our jail, where I am in Atlanta, we actually have a section that is strictly
01:12:27.270 --> 01:12:32.510
for those who have been diagnosed, and it's not a good place for them to be.
01:12:33.190 --> 01:12:39.150
And we had a terrible tragedy that happened right when I started working for
01:12:39.150 --> 01:12:40.570
the sheriff's office here.
01:12:41.250 --> 01:12:45.050
Thank goodness we weren't involved in it. It was at Georgia Tech.
01:12:45.450 --> 01:12:50.510
I don't know if you heard about it, but it was a young man who had some issues.
01:12:51.430 --> 01:12:57.290
And but he was at school and I don't know if I can't remember if his parents
01:12:57.290 --> 01:13:01.830
said he had stopped taking his medication or whatever but somebody called and
01:13:01.830 --> 01:13:08.230
said there's a guy with a knife on campus so the campus police responded and
01:13:08.230 --> 01:13:10.570
he was out in the middle of the street with the knife.
01:13:11.730 --> 01:13:16.050
And you know the officers said put the knife down he wouldn't put it down so
01:13:16.050 --> 01:13:17.290
they shot him and they killed them.
01:13:18.010 --> 01:13:22.890
And then they realized, you know, afterwards, you know, and a lot of times the
01:13:22.890 --> 01:13:27.610
term in law enforcement, they say when people do that, they say that's suicide
01:13:27.610 --> 01:13:29.930
by cop. That's the term I used.
01:13:30.750 --> 01:13:38.630
And so the parents really have been trying since then to work with law enforcement
01:13:38.630 --> 01:13:46.170
here in Georgia and in the state legislature to try to get laws changed or at least, you know,
01:13:46.410 --> 01:13:51.910
even in the police training standards to be more sensitive to situations like that.
01:13:52.210 --> 01:13:58.250
But having gone through intensive training, they still train us to shoot people.
01:13:58.370 --> 01:14:00.450
I'm just being honest, you know.
01:14:01.170 --> 01:14:05.210
And so I think that you touched on that.
01:14:05.330 --> 01:14:10.190
And I think that's something real that we need to look at.
01:14:10.590 --> 01:14:16.490
And like I said, let me get off that rabbit trail. But I'm just saying you were
01:14:16.490 --> 01:14:19.550
spot on in what you highlighted on that.
01:14:20.725 --> 01:14:27.085
Stated in the book that Philippe Pinel wrote that the highest calling of the
01:14:27.085 --> 01:14:31.065
psychiatric doctor was understanding each patient's hopes and dreams.
01:14:31.305 --> 01:14:38.605
So my question is, are hopes and dreams unattainable in today's mental health system?
01:14:39.105 --> 01:14:43.265
I think what's unattainable is a situation in which you actually have a doctor
01:14:43.265 --> 01:14:45.605
who understands what they are.
01:14:45.845 --> 01:14:49.465
I mean, Pinel was saying, and Pinel was an absolutely amazing guy.
01:14:49.705 --> 01:14:55.325
And if you're interested in him out there, people, I wrote a column about him for Psychology Today.
01:14:55.325 --> 01:15:00.345
It was called For a Better Psychiatry, Go Back 200 Years, because he did not,
01:15:00.565 --> 01:15:03.405
you know, he went into Paris in
01:15:03.405 --> 01:15:08.385
the late 1700s, and people were literally treated with whips and chains.
01:15:08.665 --> 01:15:12.345
And he released most of his patients, and they were cured.
01:15:13.105 --> 01:15:16.825
So he demanded of the revolutionary government that they do better.
01:15:17.065 --> 01:15:20.865
And he demanded of himself and everyone who worked with him that they spend
01:15:20.865 --> 01:15:23.645
a lot of time with those patients.
01:15:24.005 --> 01:15:26.905
He said it was not as important to understand.
01:15:27.665 --> 01:15:32.205
Well, he went back to Hippocrates, who said it's much more important to understand
01:15:32.205 --> 01:15:34.345
the patient than to understand the disease.
01:15:34.685 --> 01:15:38.145
And he basically took that to heart.
01:15:38.225 --> 01:15:43.225
And he said the smartest move in medication is knowing when not to use it.
01:15:43.465 --> 01:15:47.565
But he said that unless you understood your patient really, really well,
01:15:47.805 --> 01:15:51.605
unless you understood what mattered to them, their hopes and dreams,
01:15:51.825 --> 01:15:53.785
that you could not treat them.
01:15:53.945 --> 01:15:58.585
And so we have this weird bifurcation where now you basically go to the psychiatrist
01:15:58.585 --> 01:16:00.685
for your prescription and your renewals.
01:16:01.285 --> 01:16:07.885
And it would have horrified Pinel, who started a movement called the Moral Treatment
01:16:07.885 --> 01:16:12.585
that went on for quite a while and actually worked extremely well. Yeah.
01:16:14.036 --> 01:16:19.356
Speaking about treatment, why is it important to consider holistic methods of treatment?
01:16:20.056 --> 01:16:23.896
Well, sure. I mean, one of the things we know now, and this is something that's
01:16:23.896 --> 01:16:28.156
not any longer something we can argue about because it's so well proven,
01:16:28.336 --> 01:16:30.556
is that antidepressants in
01:16:30.556 --> 01:16:35.296
a lot of studies don't come in or come in at the same level as placebos.
01:16:35.916 --> 01:16:39.956
Placebos and depression actually work 30 to 40 percent of the time if you don't
01:16:39.956 --> 01:16:47.296
know it's a placebo. They don't always even match the results of exercise, things like yoga.
01:16:47.896 --> 01:16:51.236
One thing I'm writing about right now is called social prescribing.
01:16:51.236 --> 01:16:56.796
It's very big in the UK where doctors will prescribe walks, classes,
01:16:57.056 --> 01:16:59.096
museum visits rather than drugs.
01:16:59.976 --> 01:17:04.556
So, I mean, I said this earlier, and I can only reiterate it. We know a lot.
01:17:05.116 --> 01:17:09.436
Northern Italy has made huge strides with getting people off the streets that's
01:17:09.436 --> 01:17:11.776
virtually not happening there.
01:17:12.456 --> 01:17:16.416
I think they're walking back on it a little bit, but they've had just tremendous
01:17:16.416 --> 01:17:21.236
success closing the institutions and keeping people engaged in their lives.
01:17:21.896 --> 01:17:25.676
What's sad to me is that we do have all this evidence of what can help,
01:17:25.676 --> 01:17:29.616
and we're just not using it. We're not committing the resources to it.
01:17:29.916 --> 01:17:37.356
So I do go back to Pinnell. I think he's just a fantastic model for all of this.
01:17:38.196 --> 01:17:42.056
Yeah. Why do you think, in your opinion,
01:17:42.236 --> 01:17:51.916
that is that we don't put the resources into mental health and exploring as
01:17:51.916 --> 01:17:55.856
many different ways to deal with,
01:17:56.536 --> 01:18:00.296
I know you don't like to term mental illness, but how do you, how,
01:18:01.056 --> 01:18:06.016
why do you think it is that we don't prioritize it? Because one thing you said in the book was that.
01:18:07.204 --> 01:18:13.124
Lot of us, you know, are saying, well, the pandemic kind of exposed a lot of stuff, right?
01:18:13.444 --> 01:18:19.164
But you make the argument that, you know, we were heading that way before the pandemic hit.
01:18:19.744 --> 01:18:26.004
We were, yes. Why do you think that we, you know, we don't prioritize it the way that we should?
01:18:26.964 --> 01:18:30.724
Because of a lot of mythologies about mental health that I think,
01:18:30.844 --> 01:18:36.664
you know, are often based on stigmas or just based on misinformation, that it's in your genes.
01:18:37.384 --> 01:18:41.764
That's been kind of an absurdly exaggerated thing.
01:18:41.904 --> 01:18:45.144
There is some genetic connection, but it's much smaller than most people think,
01:18:45.144 --> 01:18:47.664
and it's much more likely to be life experience.
01:18:48.224 --> 01:18:52.924
So we think it's genes. We think it's brain processes, that you can stay on
01:18:52.924 --> 01:18:55.224
medication for life, but you can't fix these.
01:18:55.504 --> 01:18:57.804
We think things like schizophrenia are hopeless.
01:18:58.204 --> 01:19:01.304
I mean, one of the scenes in the book is when I heard at 15 that I was going
01:19:01.304 --> 01:19:04.004
to live in an institution. Here I am.
01:19:05.644 --> 01:19:11.004
Schizophrenia, actually a third of the time, the first episode never recurs. People are just okay.
01:19:11.744 --> 01:19:17.644
And then another third may stay on some kind of care, but are going to do well
01:19:17.644 --> 01:19:18.944
in life. They're going to do pretty well.
01:19:19.064 --> 01:19:21.164
And another third may not, but
01:19:21.164 --> 01:19:24.704
I think, again, we're doing things that we already know don't really work.
01:19:25.024 --> 01:19:29.044
But the system works for the pharmaceutical companies. It works really well
01:19:29.044 --> 01:19:32.764
for the insurance companies. They can justify these 15-minute visits.
01:19:33.264 --> 01:19:37.264
I mean, one of the first books that kind of announced this new way of,
01:19:37.364 --> 01:19:41.464
you know, not treating people psychologically, not talking about life,
01:19:41.624 --> 01:19:44.784
getting away from Freud, was this book called The Broken Brain,
01:19:45.044 --> 01:19:47.664
The Biological Revolution in Psychiatry.
01:19:48.004 --> 01:19:52.644
And the author said, it's great, you can spend 15 minutes with a doctor, not an hour a week.
01:19:53.665 --> 01:19:57.505
Does most of us need that? It might not be an hour a week, but we need life
01:19:57.505 --> 01:20:00.125
interventions. We need help. We need alternatives.
01:20:00.425 --> 01:20:04.525
We might need social prescriptions for walks and museums. I mean,
01:20:04.585 --> 01:20:07.485
so many different things can help. It's complex.
01:20:07.985 --> 01:20:13.645
And this myth, the story of neurotransmitters, you know, we now know serotonin
01:20:13.645 --> 01:20:17.865
doesn't cause depression, either less or more of it. That's been disproven.
01:20:18.425 --> 01:20:24.485
But it's such a nice story. You know, we can do this so fast and we can put
01:20:24.485 --> 01:20:29.565
very little money into it and give people inexpensive drugs, but it hasn't worked.
01:20:29.645 --> 01:20:33.165
We've given it a chance. It's time to try something different.
01:20:33.605 --> 01:20:39.245
So what do you want readers to take away from this book when they get it?
01:20:39.985 --> 01:20:44.665
I would love for readers to understand that neurodiversity, like mine,
01:20:44.825 --> 01:20:48.725
which people will probably consider pretty extreme, I've hallucinated, but,
01:20:49.398 --> 01:20:53.178
It is its own way of knowing. It's not meaningless and it's not pointless,
01:20:53.178 --> 01:20:56.798
which was something Dorothea Buck was such a great champion for saying,
01:20:57.098 --> 01:21:00.558
that it's something that you can learn from and can even be transformative,
01:21:01.158 --> 01:21:02.858
that there's always hope,
01:21:03.558 --> 01:21:10.358
and that human beings are very complex, and it's rare that there's only one thing going on.
01:21:10.518 --> 01:21:15.418
Certainly, there could be, but with mental states and traits,
01:21:15.578 --> 01:21:19.838
it's rare that there's only one thing going on, And so there is a lot of hope
01:21:19.838 --> 01:21:26.578
and keep trying and make sure you get a doctor that respects you if you can. That's hard. Yeah.
01:21:27.358 --> 01:21:32.458
So I'm a big sports guy and I grew up in Chicago, so I'm a big Chicago sports guy.
01:21:33.018 --> 01:21:38.998
And I'll never forget, there was a young man that played for the Bears named Alonzo Spellman.
01:21:39.938 --> 01:21:43.478
And he was, you know, I think he had an all pro season.
01:21:43.558 --> 01:21:46.538
He was one of the top defensive ends in the league.
01:21:46.538 --> 01:21:49.298
And one day during the
01:21:49.298 --> 01:21:52.498
off season he was walking around lakeshore drive
01:21:52.498 --> 01:21:55.538
naked and you know the police
01:21:55.538 --> 01:21:58.438
fortunately the police recognized who
01:21:58.438 --> 01:22:04.158
he was and they got him to the station they called the bears organization and
01:22:04.158 --> 01:22:12.798
all that stuff and so what the bears did you know was they they called around
01:22:12.798 --> 01:22:16.538
to see who would take him in a trade.
01:22:17.478 --> 01:22:22.798
And so, and they explained why they wanted to trade him because they didn't
01:22:22.798 --> 01:22:28.638
have the personnel in their, you know, in their medical team to deal with that.
01:22:28.938 --> 01:22:33.198
And I think they do now. I think most of the teams do now, but the team that
01:22:33.198 --> 01:22:36.578
had the best treatment was Dallas.
01:22:37.698 --> 01:22:43.578
And so they traded him to Dallas and he continued his football career at least
01:22:43.578 --> 01:22:48.798
for a couple more years because he was getting the treatment that he needed and all that stuff.
01:22:49.058 --> 01:22:52.398
So it's very important for people to.
01:22:54.493 --> 01:22:58.033
You said take the stigma off and do what they had to do. The Bears could have
01:22:58.033 --> 01:23:02.373
been very selfish and, you know, try to keep it under wraps and all that kind
01:23:02.373 --> 01:23:06.293
of stuff and just throw him out there on the field because he was a good player for them.
01:23:06.613 --> 01:23:11.493
But they took it upon themselves and said, no, we care about this individual.
01:23:11.933 --> 01:23:16.213
And if we can get him on a team where he can still play football and get the
01:23:16.213 --> 01:23:19.253
help that he needs, then that's what we're going to do.
01:23:19.953 --> 01:23:23.913
And I just wish that more people would do that, and I hope that,
01:23:24.493 --> 01:23:30.553
People reading your book will get more of a sense of that and understand that
01:23:30.553 --> 01:23:34.513
some of the things that are happening now, especially people that are dealing
01:23:34.513 --> 01:23:38.393
with issues, you know, there's there's a history behind it.
01:23:38.393 --> 01:23:43.953
And we're still at a point where we're, you know, when you were talking about
01:23:43.953 --> 01:23:47.033
the guy Kraepelin, right?
01:23:47.613 --> 01:23:55.593
And in my mind, I was thinking, yeah, they called him a founder of modern psychology,
01:23:55.593 --> 01:23:59.113
but he was doing it for the wrong reasons, right?
01:23:59.813 --> 01:24:07.473
Absolutely. And then I thought about Wernher von Braun, who was a scientist
01:24:07.473 --> 01:24:09.993
for the Nazis building rockets.
01:24:10.193 --> 01:24:14.353
And we stole them. And he built our NASA program.
01:24:14.853 --> 01:24:19.233
So there could be some good to come out of it.
01:24:20.564 --> 01:24:24.164
But I didn't get that from the book. But, you know, but maybe,
01:24:24.184 --> 01:24:29.944
maybe there's, I guess there was some things that he kind of touched on that,
01:24:30.164 --> 01:24:35.384
I guess, helps people in the profession deal with their clients.
01:24:36.044 --> 01:24:40.324
You know, but I just, it was really, really very eye-opening.
01:24:40.584 --> 01:24:43.924
Even, I haven't seen the movie Nuremberg yet. Have you seen it?
01:24:44.724 --> 01:24:49.484
I have not. You know, I wrote quite a bit about that guy, Douglas Kelly,
01:24:49.704 --> 01:24:51.524
who was the Nuremberg psychiatrist.
01:24:52.524 --> 01:24:58.024
And I kind of almost topped out on the story. I will watch it down the road.
01:24:58.344 --> 01:25:03.304
He was fascinating. I mean, he became very obsessed with the fact that none
01:25:03.304 --> 01:25:08.084
of the Nazi doctors really were disturbed in any way. He wanted them to be.
01:25:08.264 --> 01:25:12.824
He wanted an easy answer. But he ultimately said they were like businessmen,
01:25:13.044 --> 01:25:16.844
except they considered their business world domination.
01:25:17.644 --> 01:25:20.844
I mean, they were very dry, cut and dry about it. And none of them,
01:25:20.984 --> 01:25:23.484
you know, they passed every psych test they were given.
01:25:24.344 --> 01:25:28.644
Yeah, well, I think you brought a different angle. I think the movie is more
01:25:28.644 --> 01:25:33.224
about the trial part, etc., and not about the prep before.
01:25:33.224 --> 01:25:40.204
But yeah you get into it so deep that you know one of the things that you highlighted
01:25:40.204 --> 01:25:46.424
was the fact that the I don't know if this was at the main trial or the doctor's trial but.
01:25:47.787 --> 01:25:51.527
I think the movie is about the very first trial, where it's like the United
01:25:51.527 --> 01:25:53.907
States and a couple other countries were involved.
01:25:54.187 --> 01:25:56.727
But the doctor's trial was strictly us.
01:25:57.447 --> 01:26:04.307
And the part of the defense was that the United States really shouldn't have
01:26:04.307 --> 01:26:09.007
any standing in this court because of the Tuskegee experiments.
01:26:09.647 --> 01:26:13.627
Yeah, that did come up. Yeah. No, I'm sorry. I was actually thinking,
01:26:13.687 --> 01:26:15.107
I think, of a different film.
01:26:15.387 --> 01:26:19.727
But I haven't seen the Nuremberg film. But yes, I'm very familiar with what they said.
01:26:19.967 --> 01:26:23.547
And, you know, one of the reasons that we didn't, you know, one of the reasons
01:26:23.547 --> 01:26:27.567
that the crimes against the psychiatric population wasn't prosecuted,
01:26:27.807 --> 01:26:31.247
weren't prosecuted, was that it was German on German crime.
01:26:31.687 --> 01:26:35.107
And people in the U.S. are kind of saying, well, if we do that to them,
01:26:35.267 --> 01:26:38.347
what are they going to come in here and do to us?
01:26:38.947 --> 01:26:45.227
If we're going to target crime against your own population, how are we going
01:26:45.227 --> 01:26:49.347
to look, you know, on that, you know, sitting in that defense box?
01:26:49.347 --> 01:26:55.367
So, yes, that is very real that it was a concern that we had done the Tuskegee
01:26:55.367 --> 01:27:01.507
experiments and we were, you know, we were prosecuting them for experiments they did. Yeah.
01:27:02.347 --> 01:27:06.227
On humans. Now, I think the man you mentioned, Kelly, right?
01:27:06.867 --> 01:27:13.707
Doug Kelly, yeah. He even said that he had a fear that because of racism that
01:27:13.707 --> 01:27:16.247
we would go down that same path, right?
01:27:16.387 --> 01:27:18.707
Oh, absolutely. He was, yeah.
01:27:19.347 --> 01:27:25.167
He was kind of obsessively afraid of that. And I think he was wise. Yeah.
01:27:25.727 --> 01:27:29.507
All right. So let's close out on an optimistic note.
01:27:31.267 --> 01:27:38.327
Sure. I'm asking all the guests to do this. Finish this sentence. I have hope because...
01:27:39.586 --> 01:27:41.226
Have hope because we actually do
01:27:41.226 --> 01:27:44.846
know what we need to do. We have a lot of information on things that work.
01:27:44.986 --> 01:27:50.406
And because I think that people like Dorothea Buck, people like Douglas Kelly,
01:27:51.006 --> 01:27:55.266
people like Paul Schraber, people like DJ Mason, who wrote that story for Ebony,
01:27:55.466 --> 01:28:00.606
these people come along who just demand change and they know how to, they can affect change.
01:28:00.726 --> 01:28:02.666
And I think those people are going to come along again.
01:28:02.846 --> 01:28:05.686
And Philippe Pinel, Tremendous human being.
01:28:05.926 --> 01:28:11.366
I mean, the good news is what one human being can do. And the answer to that is almost everything.
01:28:12.486 --> 01:28:18.046
So how can people get the book? How can people reach out to you? All that stuff. Sure.
01:28:18.686 --> 01:28:22.786
The book is The Devil's Castle. It's on audio. You know, it's on Audible.
01:28:23.066 --> 01:28:28.766
It's available at any bookstore, Amazon, bookshelf.org, whatever your preference is.
01:28:28.946 --> 01:28:34.766
And my website is suzantonetta.com. and I do answer my mail.
01:28:35.446 --> 01:28:40.906
So reach out through my contact form, say hello, tell me your story.
01:28:41.686 --> 01:28:48.326
All right. Well, Susanne, I greatly appreciate you, one, coming on the podcast
01:28:48.326 --> 01:28:50.206
and two, writing this book.
01:28:50.426 --> 01:28:56.166
I think, you know, it's an issue that I dealt with as a legislator.
01:28:56.446 --> 01:29:00.986
And I tell this story anytime I have somebody, we talk about mental health.
01:29:01.246 --> 01:29:05.386
You know, it was the one One thing I noticed that every year in the appropriations
01:29:05.386 --> 01:29:08.206
process, we were cutting the budget for that.
01:29:08.426 --> 01:29:12.626
And I had said that we were going to pay for that. And I haven't been elected
01:29:12.626 --> 01:29:15.506
official for nearly 20 years now.
01:29:15.786 --> 01:29:22.726
But I knew that if you kept, if we as a government that's supposed to follow the.
01:29:24.193 --> 01:29:26.373
Premise that we're supposed to look out for the general welfare,
01:29:26.613 --> 01:29:33.513
if we kept cutting money from our mental health, then that was going to be a
01:29:33.513 --> 01:29:36.193
problem, especially in a small state like Mississippi.
01:29:37.093 --> 01:29:41.253
And that was a national trend. That wasn't just the Mississippi thing.
01:29:41.393 --> 01:29:43.573
It was like every state legislature did that.
01:29:43.913 --> 01:29:48.973
And I think we're paying the price for that. So I hope that your book,
01:29:49.173 --> 01:29:50.473
along with some other people,
01:29:51.753 --> 01:29:59.253
you know, continues to raise the awareness that needs to happen so that it becomes more of a priority.
01:29:59.333 --> 01:30:04.253
And whenever we do get universal health care, that that mental health will be included.
01:30:04.833 --> 01:30:09.953
But I just thank you for the research. And I know that, you know,
01:30:10.353 --> 01:30:14.833
you went through some stuff while you were writing the book.
01:30:14.833 --> 01:30:19.033
And the courage that you had to push through.
01:30:19.633 --> 01:30:22.473
Yes, ladies and gentlemen, you've got to read the book to understand what I'm talking about.
01:30:23.653 --> 01:30:26.513
And just the fact that you, even though it was, like you said,
01:30:26.633 --> 01:30:31.413
only 10% and 15%, the fact that you put yourself in there.
01:30:33.773 --> 01:30:37.013
That's the storytelling that we need to get the message out.
01:30:37.133 --> 01:30:39.093
So again, I thank you for that.
01:30:39.653 --> 01:30:42.353
I thank you so much for having me. This was a great conversation.
01:30:42.713 --> 01:30:45.673
All right. All right, guys, and we're going to catch y'all on the other side.
01:31:00.967 --> 01:31:06.747
I want to thank Dr. Ellen Bassuk, her son Daniel Schoonover,
01:31:06.947 --> 01:31:12.007
and Susanne Antonetta for coming on the podcast.
01:31:12.447 --> 01:31:17.647
I greatly appreciate their vulnerability
01:31:17.647 --> 01:31:24.607
and their scholarship in the two books they have written. Dr.
01:31:24.707 --> 01:31:33.587
Ellen and her son Daniel wrote Between Two Worlds, and Miss Susanne wrote The Devil's Castle.
01:31:34.007 --> 01:31:39.607
If you are into this issue and you really want to see some changes,
01:31:40.367 --> 01:31:42.707
you really need to read those books.
01:31:43.527 --> 01:31:47.847
I think, you know, the perspectives that they bring, again,
01:31:47.847 --> 01:31:51.707
with the combination of being vulnerable and being scholarly,
01:31:51.707 --> 01:31:57.887
It really does justice to the awareness, and we need to continue,
01:31:57.887 --> 01:32:05.987
we really need to continue to push this issue because this happens.
01:32:06.107 --> 01:32:09.207
It can happen to any one of us because all of us have brains.
01:32:10.347 --> 01:32:15.287
And, you know, our mental health is as important, if not more important,
01:32:15.447 --> 01:32:16.387
than our physical health.
01:32:17.347 --> 01:32:22.367
It's got to be a balance. And like I said to Ms.
01:32:22.407 --> 01:32:27.787
Susanne, I pray that if we do ever get universal health care in the United States,
01:32:27.787 --> 01:32:31.387
that mental health is a major component in that as well.
01:32:31.687 --> 01:32:37.507
Because everybody wants to look good, you know, feel good as far as like running
01:32:37.507 --> 01:32:42.627
or playing the sport. They want to play recreationally, all that kind of stuff.
01:32:42.787 --> 01:32:48.847
But you got to have a sound mind. And for those of you who have followed me
01:32:48.847 --> 01:32:56.367
on the podcast, you know that I have been very open about my battle with depression.
01:32:57.507 --> 01:33:00.267
I am very fortunate that.
01:33:01.660 --> 01:33:09.260
Even with my stubbornness and the personal relationships that I lost because
01:33:09.260 --> 01:33:16.240
of it, that I was able to get diagnosed and treated.
01:33:17.200 --> 01:33:24.300
And so far, I've been okay. I have moments, but I'm not in that funk that I was in.
01:33:24.500 --> 01:33:29.460
When I tell you I was not in a good place, I was not in a good place.
01:33:31.460 --> 01:33:37.660
And, you know, even from a spiritual standpoint, I had such a strong connection.
01:33:39.460 --> 01:33:44.740
And it was it was like it was just like you, you know, for those of us old enough
01:33:44.740 --> 01:33:52.940
to remember dial up on AOL, you know, you would hear the the the chirping noise or whatever.
01:33:53.620 --> 01:33:58.320
And and then sometimes you would just get cut off and you had no access at all.
01:33:58.320 --> 01:34:02.260
Wasn't like, you know, it was slow or anything.
01:34:02.420 --> 01:34:04.620
I mean, it was just like off, right?
01:34:05.120 --> 01:34:11.600
And that's what I felt like. I just felt like, you know, my brain, I was just on autopilot.
01:34:12.960 --> 01:34:21.960
And, you know, it was until I got treatment, you know, I just kind of felt defenseless on that.
01:34:22.440 --> 01:34:28.820
So, And like I said, even when I was an elected official, it was an issue for me.
01:34:30.140 --> 01:34:35.560
And it might explain when I critique myself.
01:34:37.148 --> 01:34:40.208
Level of maturity in the position I had.
01:34:41.268 --> 01:34:45.488
Because, you know, depression is not something that just pops up.
01:34:45.848 --> 01:34:48.868
You know, it's something that builds over time.
01:34:49.128 --> 01:34:56.788
It's, you know, disappointment, tragedy, trauma, whatever combination you run into, right?
01:34:57.368 --> 01:35:01.188
You know, self-esteem, all that kind of stuff that just builds up.
01:35:01.288 --> 01:35:05.788
And if you don't fortify yourself, It can it can happen.
01:35:06.368 --> 01:35:12.708
So, you know, it's like we have a natural moment of being depressed,
01:35:12.708 --> 01:35:18.408
but when it takes over, it's not not good.
01:35:18.408 --> 01:35:28.348
And so I commend my guests for being vulnerable and letting people know it's
01:35:28.348 --> 01:35:33.888
like we see the challenges out there, but they also see hope.
01:35:34.568 --> 01:35:40.748
And that's kind of the way I want to close out, you know, because it's like
01:35:40.748 --> 01:35:46.068
in the political world, we're seeing a lot of challenges, right?
01:35:46.648 --> 01:35:50.248
We've seen two members of Congress resign.
01:35:50.828 --> 01:35:55.768
Within the span of two weeks, we've lost two elected officials to violence,
01:35:56.348 --> 01:36:03.008
domestic violence, and two African-American officials at that.
01:36:03.568 --> 01:36:08.268
So you never know when it's going to hit.
01:36:08.908 --> 01:36:14.088
I do have some pushback with the Congresswoman we refer to as AOC.
01:36:16.028 --> 01:36:22.448
Congresswoman Ocasio-Cortez you know she was stopped by some reporters and they
01:36:22.448 --> 01:36:27.128
asked her what her thoughts were about what was going on at the Capitol and
01:36:27.128 --> 01:36:32.588
she said well we just got to get some people that you know have strong moral
01:36:32.588 --> 01:36:34.088
character and all that stuff,
01:36:34.868 --> 01:36:37.148
and my pushback is good luck on that,
01:36:37.948 --> 01:36:40.968
because all of us are human that.
01:36:42.252 --> 01:36:47.212
We just laid to rest a man who said in one of his famous quotes,
01:36:47.732 --> 01:36:50.932
not a perfect servant. I'm a public servant.
01:36:51.952 --> 01:37:00.132
I think the challenge for us is if we want to do good in society,
01:37:00.132 --> 01:37:03.352
if we want to make things better for people,
01:37:04.152 --> 01:37:11.472
doing whatever personal demons, whatever challenges you have, it can't stop that.
01:37:12.332 --> 01:37:18.172
And if it's getting to a point where you can't do good, then you need to address it.
01:37:19.212 --> 01:37:24.072
There are some people that think, well, you know, I can compartmentalize it.
01:37:24.552 --> 01:37:27.732
And, you know, when I'm off the clock or when I'm not in public,
01:37:27.732 --> 01:37:29.212
I can do whatever I want to.
01:37:29.392 --> 01:37:34.892
And then I can get out and do what I do.
01:37:36.332 --> 01:37:40.052
And politicians fall into that trap a lot.
01:37:41.612 --> 01:37:49.972
And so I just want to say that everything that you do impacts you.
01:37:50.552 --> 01:37:55.412
If it's something that is going to compromise you, then it's going to diminish
01:37:55.412 --> 01:37:58.812
what you can do good, right?
01:37:59.732 --> 01:38:01.712
So I'm not here to judge anybody.
01:38:02.752 --> 01:38:05.792
I think the actions that have been taken needed to be taken.
01:38:05.792 --> 01:38:12.252
I think there's a couple of other folks that might need to reevaluate why they're
01:38:12.252 --> 01:38:20.552
in Congress and they need to decide to step down themselves instead of prolonging a fight.
01:38:21.092 --> 01:38:26.892
But that's on them. You know, that's about as nonpartisan as it can be.
01:38:27.412 --> 01:38:30.112
Doesn't matter if you're a Democrat, Republican, Independent,
01:38:30.492 --> 01:38:37.472
Green, whatever. You know, if you did something and you know that that goes against,
01:38:39.065 --> 01:38:44.685
So what you're trying to do, if it negates the good that you're doing,
01:38:45.325 --> 01:38:46.905
then you need to address that.
01:38:48.605 --> 01:38:53.045
And for the good that you did do, people will appreciate that.
01:38:53.605 --> 01:38:59.565
Maybe not on a mass scale like you were used to, but the people that you help
01:38:59.565 --> 01:39:01.485
will always remember that you helped them.
01:39:02.025 --> 01:39:07.125
And that's the satisfaction you can take even if you're no longer in public life.
01:39:07.625 --> 01:39:11.465
If you did some good while you were there, you did some good.
01:39:12.085 --> 01:39:14.325
But you can't hold on to that forever.
01:39:16.085 --> 01:39:24.225
And, you know, it would be nice if we had people of the highest,
01:39:24.525 --> 01:39:27.825
of highest characters in elective office.
01:39:28.145 --> 01:39:36.145
That's a dream, right? But when you're looking at 435 options,
01:39:36.945 --> 01:39:38.825
you're not going to get perfection.
01:39:39.285 --> 01:39:42.585
Even with 100 options, you're not going to get perfection.
01:39:44.265 --> 01:39:48.765
And that's just Congress. I mean, we ain't got to the judges.
01:39:49.885 --> 01:39:57.005
We haven't got to the state legislators, right, who have a high profile in their
01:39:57.005 --> 01:40:01.445
state. But if you don't live in their state, you don't know who these people are, right?
01:40:02.265 --> 01:40:06.905
You know, because we've had, I've had colleagues, you know, think,
01:40:07.025 --> 01:40:10.085
well, I'm not in my state, so I can do what I want to do.
01:40:11.045 --> 01:40:16.525
And it comes back to bite them. It happens when you decide to do something that
01:40:16.525 --> 01:40:19.665
you know you ain't supposed to be doing and come back and get you.
01:40:21.085 --> 01:40:27.545
So I am the last person to judge anybody. I have not lived anywhere close to a perfect life.
01:40:28.145 --> 01:40:32.885
All I ask people to do is do what's good for folks.
01:40:33.185 --> 01:40:36.445
Fulfill the obligation that's in the preamble, right?
01:40:36.885 --> 01:40:38.725
To promote the general welfare.
01:40:39.645 --> 01:40:42.625
You're supposed to provide a, provide defense.
01:40:44.134 --> 01:40:47.834
And the key word is defense. That's why we called it the Department of Defense
01:40:47.834 --> 01:40:52.694
instead of Department of War, because we're not supposed to be going out starting stuff.
01:40:53.234 --> 01:40:57.554
We're supposed to be strong enough that when the time comes,
01:40:57.574 --> 01:40:59.754
we can defend our nation.
01:41:00.374 --> 01:41:05.414
That's the psychology behind the name defense as opposed to war.
01:41:05.414 --> 01:41:08.794
When you say you're the Department of War, you're basically saying,
01:41:09.034 --> 01:41:14.334
I am the descendant of the war god Ares, and we're going to take over the world.
01:41:14.494 --> 01:41:16.914
That's, you know, that's not what we do.
01:41:17.774 --> 01:41:24.194
We defend the United States of America. We don't, we're not supposed to be bullying
01:41:24.194 --> 01:41:26.214
the rest of the planet, right?
01:41:26.954 --> 01:41:31.174
Even though we are imperialistic in the way that we do things,
01:41:31.514 --> 01:41:34.534
we're not really an empire. We're not supposed to be.
01:41:35.414 --> 01:41:41.314
You know, we can, the strength of us, especially after World War II,
01:41:41.674 --> 01:41:47.274
is that the world knew that we could hold our own and help our friends when they need it.
01:41:47.694 --> 01:41:55.114
And we channel that through USAID and we channel that through diplomacy, that power.
01:41:56.034 --> 01:41:59.974
You know, we are the only nation that ever dropped a nuclear weapon on anybody.
01:42:01.854 --> 01:42:05.454
So people have that in the back of their minds. They understand that. Thank you.
01:42:06.622 --> 01:42:11.742
So, you know, we're supposed to come in with a position of strength,
01:42:11.742 --> 01:42:15.582
but not a position of intimidation, right?
01:42:16.702 --> 01:42:23.182
And if you have flawed individuals in positions, that compromises our strength.
01:42:24.082 --> 01:42:27.102
But are we going to get perfect individuals? No.
01:42:28.022 --> 01:42:35.182
Case in point, Donald Trump is a flawed individual, right? Bill Clinton was not perfect.
01:42:36.122 --> 01:42:39.382
Jimmy Carter was not perfect, right?
01:42:40.902 --> 01:42:44.942
He was of higher moral character than the other two guys I just mentioned.
01:42:45.222 --> 01:42:48.142
But, you know, Barack Obama is not perfect.
01:42:49.682 --> 01:42:56.462
But, you know, when you talk about people who set aside money they could make,
01:42:57.242 --> 01:42:59.222
circles they could run in,
01:43:00.690 --> 01:43:06.610
just offer themselves up for service to the nation, you know,
01:43:07.170 --> 01:43:09.690
there's an understanding that they're human.
01:43:10.390 --> 01:43:15.430
And it used to be a time where it was like through the vetting process of the
01:43:15.430 --> 01:43:22.270
primaries and the election, if you found out this person wasn't all that,
01:43:22.850 --> 01:43:29.430
you know, that's going to compromise us, then we didn't vote for them, right?
01:43:29.930 --> 01:43:35.810
And it wasn't personal. It was just like, yeah, dude, you sound good, but what about this?
01:43:36.530 --> 01:43:41.030
Like Gary Hart, for example, right? The senator from, I think he was from Colorado.
01:43:42.330 --> 01:43:45.970
Senator Hart was supposed to be the Democratic nominee in 1984.
01:43:45.990 --> 01:43:49.970
He was supposed to be the Vice President, Vice President Mondale.
01:43:50.970 --> 01:43:54.250
But word got out that he was having an affair.
01:43:55.030 --> 01:44:04.490
But instead of nixing that, right, instead of saying, look, I can't see you
01:44:04.490 --> 01:44:06.690
anymore, whatever the case may be, right?
01:44:07.790 --> 01:44:14.450
I got to be president. He dared the press, literally dared them to follow him.
01:44:14.670 --> 01:44:17.950
If you think that I'm having an affair, then follow me.
01:44:18.930 --> 01:44:23.310
Well, somebody took him up on that offer and caught him in an act.
01:44:24.010 --> 01:44:30.310
So Gary Hart's issue wasn't the infidelity. It was judgment, arrogance.
01:44:31.250 --> 01:44:35.850
You think that you could do what you want and be above reproach?
01:44:36.670 --> 01:44:41.250
That's not the person we need to have the nuclear codes.
01:44:41.410 --> 01:44:47.430
That's not the person we need in that Oval Office sitting at that resolute desk.
01:44:48.230 --> 01:44:50.210
That's the way we were in 1984.
01:44:51.090 --> 01:44:54.130
We are obviously lax on that now.
01:44:54.970 --> 01:45:00.070
Because if we were going by 1984 standards, Donald Trump wouldn't have made
01:45:00.070 --> 01:45:01.330
it out of the Republican primary.
01:45:01.810 --> 01:45:03.610
No way, shape or form.
01:45:05.217 --> 01:45:09.697
Way more arrogant than Gary Hart. He can't even say I'm sorry.
01:45:09.937 --> 01:45:11.957
He can't even say I made a mistake.
01:45:12.557 --> 01:45:16.237
So he definitely thinks he's beyond reproach, right?
01:45:17.557 --> 01:45:21.997
That's why old cats like me can't get into him.
01:45:22.717 --> 01:45:26.437
If we were just having the typical Democrat-Republican arguments,
01:45:27.397 --> 01:45:30.537
you know, you don't want to get a George Bush in there.
01:45:30.897 --> 01:45:35.957
You don't want to get George H.W. Bush in there, right? You're going to get a Ronald Reagan.
01:45:36.617 --> 01:45:38.277
You're going to have a back and forth.
01:45:40.477 --> 01:45:47.297
But, you know, and it was understood to a degree that these people were not perfect people.
01:45:47.677 --> 01:45:49.697
But could you sit down and have a drink with them?
01:45:50.137 --> 01:45:54.337
Could you talk shit to them about sports, about politics, about whatever?
01:45:55.157 --> 01:45:57.397
You know, they were your neighbor.
01:45:58.457 --> 01:46:02.397
Could you go to church with them? Could you hang out? Could you go to their
01:46:02.397 --> 01:46:05.017
backyard party? Could they come to your barbecue?
01:46:05.557 --> 01:46:10.997
Do you trust them to make the right decisions for the nation?
01:46:11.597 --> 01:46:16.617
That's the standard. Not perfection. Empathy.
01:46:17.777 --> 01:46:19.457
A sense of duty and honor.
01:46:21.152 --> 01:46:27.152
Not greed, not avarice, not a thirst for power.
01:46:28.192 --> 01:46:30.352
That's why I'm critical of the president.
01:46:31.452 --> 01:46:35.832
Have disagreements about policy all day long because if the end goal,
01:46:35.992 --> 01:46:39.592
if your goal or my goal is to do something to make the nation better,
01:46:39.852 --> 01:46:43.532
we're different individuals. So we're going to have different ideas.
01:46:44.092 --> 01:46:50.352
That's understood. That's part of the reason why you have those deliberative bodies.
01:46:51.152 --> 01:47:00.272
To have conversations because conversations and arguments are supposed to lead to solutions.
01:47:01.212 --> 01:47:02.512
That's the end goal.
01:47:03.572 --> 01:47:08.532
But if you can't admit that you made a mistake, if you can't even say I'm sorry,
01:47:09.572 --> 01:47:13.232
or you misunderstood what I said.
01:47:15.004 --> 01:47:18.164
That wasn't my intention. You can't say that.
01:47:19.004 --> 01:47:23.324
You're a dangerous person to be given that much responsibility.
01:47:24.404 --> 01:47:29.024
That's my beef. You can be mad because your gas is $5.
01:47:29.844 --> 01:47:36.064
You could be mad that we're in a war that we weren't supposed to be in.
01:47:36.064 --> 01:47:39.764
All those are valid issues, right?
01:47:40.364 --> 01:47:47.664
And we're not doing enough to stop genocide in Gaza or the Congo or anywhere
01:47:47.664 --> 01:47:52.304
else, you know, the Uyghurs in China.
01:47:52.904 --> 01:47:59.664
You can be mad about that, right? That's legitimate. But you should care enough
01:47:59.664 --> 01:48:04.524
where even if you have disagreements, that you look at the people that's out
01:48:04.524 --> 01:48:07.864
there and you look at where their heart is.
01:48:08.604 --> 01:48:17.164
And that should determine who we designate as the leader, because he's not just the leader for us.
01:48:17.164 --> 01:48:24.464
He is the representative of us on the planet, in the political world,
01:48:24.884 --> 01:48:26.964
amongst other nation states.
01:48:27.884 --> 01:48:35.824
That's the standard. And it'd been nice to say she, but we haven't gotten the
01:48:35.824 --> 01:48:38.824
courage to vote for a she yet.
01:48:40.616 --> 01:48:44.976
Us, because we should have had two by now, at least two.
01:48:45.956 --> 01:48:53.836
So anyway, you know, I wish that we could elect perfect people.
01:48:54.896 --> 01:49:01.896
You know, the CIA targets Brigham Young University, right, for recruitment,
01:49:01.896 --> 01:49:06.276
because most of the young men,
01:49:06.636 --> 01:49:10.196
young women that go on missions, they have to be bilingual.
01:49:10.916 --> 01:49:16.676
You know, there's a certain standard that they have to keep up on campus because
01:49:16.676 --> 01:49:17.916
it's a religious school.
01:49:18.556 --> 01:49:22.716
So things that we were doing at Jackson State, they don't do at Brigham Young.
01:49:24.156 --> 01:49:27.996
Right. Just to be clear. So, you know,
01:49:28.216 --> 01:49:32.596
they kind of profile those young men and women and say those would be ideal
01:49:32.596 --> 01:49:36.176
candidates Because when you're dealing with espionage, you've got to deal with
01:49:36.176 --> 01:49:40.596
people that have a moral compass that can't be compromised, right?
01:49:41.436 --> 01:49:44.616
In the military, the standard's not that high.
01:49:45.276 --> 01:49:49.976
We want you to be loyal. We don't want you to turn the guns on us if you're
01:49:49.976 --> 01:49:51.376
fighting for the United States.
01:49:53.116 --> 01:49:57.976
But the standard is not as high. And that's understood, right?
01:49:58.916 --> 01:50:04.696
But every elected official in the United States can't come from Brigham Young University, right?
01:50:05.276 --> 01:50:10.476
You could probably elect everybody from Utah, but there's not enough alumni
01:50:10.476 --> 01:50:14.816
to serve in all these positions in 50 states.
01:50:16.636 --> 01:50:22.016
But you don't have to go to Brigham Young to have high standards, right?
01:50:23.043 --> 01:50:28.443
You're raised, based on your discipline, right?
01:50:29.683 --> 01:50:35.403
So there's good people out here, and there's a lot of good people that don't
01:50:35.403 --> 01:50:42.083
run because the one mistake they did make figures, well, I can't run.
01:50:42.623 --> 01:50:45.063
I don't want that coming up in the campaign.
01:50:45.883 --> 01:50:53.503
And that's your call. But if you really want to do good and you can either explain
01:50:53.503 --> 01:51:00.263
or show that you've gotten past that moment and it's not going to be,
01:51:01.243 --> 01:51:05.543
indicative of how you're going to be in that job, then you should go for it.
01:51:06.363 --> 01:51:10.563
All of us have to be accountable at some point. And if you decide to run for
01:51:10.563 --> 01:51:15.603
office and you have to be accountable to the voters were something you did in the past, do it.
01:51:16.203 --> 01:51:22.343
That would say a lot more about the character because we're all going to make
01:51:22.343 --> 01:51:30.443
mistakes, no matter how disciplined we think we are, no matter how strong we think we are.
01:51:30.983 --> 01:51:33.643
We all have our kryptonite, right?
01:51:34.443 --> 01:51:42.643
So, you know, and I commend those folks who are stronger than a lot of us I
01:51:42.643 --> 01:51:48.003
commend those folks who stay above the fray as long as they can, right?
01:51:49.860 --> 01:51:57.400
You know, as much as I would like for ALC's desire to be fulfilled, it's not.
01:51:57.980 --> 01:52:02.960
But the thing is, when you got people and you know that people are doing certain
01:52:02.960 --> 01:52:08.380
things, then when they try to get beyond where you can reach them,
01:52:09.040 --> 01:52:12.400
you might want to shut that down. Especially if you can't.
01:52:12.960 --> 01:52:16.360
Or hope that the voters shut them down. Right?
01:52:19.180 --> 01:52:25.260
Because what they're doing not only impacts them, but it might impact you,
01:52:25.480 --> 01:52:27.440
especially if you're on the same side of the aisle.
01:52:28.060 --> 01:52:31.560
Well, all the Democrats are like that. All the Republicans are like that.
01:52:32.100 --> 01:52:34.480
That's just the way they are, right?
01:52:35.260 --> 01:52:38.380
And you don't want that stigma.
01:52:39.340 --> 01:52:41.680
Nonetheless, we are where we are.
01:52:42.680 --> 01:52:47.240
Ask that you pray for the families of those elected officials in Florida and
01:52:47.240 --> 01:52:52.640
Virginia, those children that either lost a parent or both parents,
01:52:52.740 --> 01:52:54.300
well, you lost both parents.
01:52:56.748 --> 01:53:03.328
That. Pray for those communities. Pray for the communities that lost their elected
01:53:03.328 --> 01:53:09.188
officials because they have to have the courage and the discernment to pick
01:53:09.188 --> 01:53:13.648
somebody else to step in that void, right?
01:53:14.468 --> 01:53:21.188
Again, we are in tough times, but the journey of the human experience is always
01:53:21.188 --> 01:53:24.168
going to be tough. There's always going to be challenges.
01:53:24.828 --> 01:53:31.388
In the Christian faith, we're taught that our sufferings build our character, right?
01:53:31.588 --> 01:53:37.148
And it gives us the strength to keep pressing for the high mark.
01:53:37.748 --> 01:53:46.008
So just summon that strength within you and get involved.
01:53:48.268 --> 01:53:51.548
Continue to support independent podcasters like me.
01:53:52.388 --> 01:53:59.968
Vote, petition, make phone calls. Do what you got to do. Stay engaged. Attend meetings.
01:54:00.588 --> 01:54:06.948
Do what you got to do. Read the newspaper. Read the online publications, whatever.
01:54:07.588 --> 01:54:10.388
Stay informed, right?
01:54:11.028 --> 01:54:18.848
Again, not asking people to be political junkies, but we need people to fulfill
01:54:18.848 --> 01:54:20.908
the obligation of citizenship.
01:54:22.108 --> 01:54:27.048
Step outside your bubble. Listen to a thought that doesn't agree with you.
01:54:27.668 --> 01:54:31.948
That was one of the most important lessons I learned in college.
01:54:32.988 --> 01:54:37.008
We had a teacher that challenged us. Step outside of the bubble.
01:54:37.488 --> 01:54:40.548
Learn what the other side is thinking.
01:54:41.128 --> 01:54:47.888
Listen to what they're saying and build your arguments that way instead of just
01:54:47.888 --> 01:54:50.028
going on emotion and comfort.
01:54:53.201 --> 01:54:56.501
So anyway, there's hope on the other side.
01:54:57.061 --> 01:55:02.521
The guess that I have, I had on today, proves that there's hope.
01:55:02.941 --> 01:55:08.621
The fact that Congress is still meeting, the Supreme Court is still functioning.
01:55:10.421 --> 01:55:16.541
Government still is there, Constitution has been burned up, Declaration of Independence
01:55:16.541 --> 01:55:19.041
is still on display. There's hope.
01:55:20.261 --> 01:55:28.801
If anything those astronauts prove that we can do things beyond people's comprehension,
01:55:29.581 --> 01:55:31.261
if you apply yourself to it.
01:55:32.741 --> 01:55:36.561
So I'll leave y'all with that, guys. We're going to get through it.
01:55:37.341 --> 01:55:40.301
Can't sit idly by and wait for somebody else to do it.
01:55:40.981 --> 01:55:45.621
You know, we had a U.S. president that challenged us and said that we are the
01:55:45.621 --> 01:55:48.801
change we want. So let's live up to that.
01:55:49.601 --> 01:55:52.481
All right, guys, thank y'all for listening. Until next time.













